Skip to main content
pilogo-NEW
Subscribe
  • Subscribe
  • My Account
  • login
  • NEWS
    • Alternatives
    • Consultants
    • Defined Contribution
    • Frontlines
    • Hedge Funds
    • Investing / Portfolio Strategies
    • Money Management
    • Pension Funds
    • People Moves
    • Private Equity
    • Real Estate
    • Searches & Hires News
    • Special Reports
    • BlackFin closes third fund at €985 million, above its target
      Alerian acquires S-Network Global Indexes
      OMERS Ventures picks Uber veteran
      Neil Sheth
      More asset owners clamoring for multistrategy private credit
    • Mercer appoints global alternatives leader for wealth business
      KPMG offloads pension advisory unit to private equity firm
      Ascensus snaps up Nyhart in latest deal
      Willis Towers Watson exec promoted to lead retirement unit
    • Drew Carrington
      New data questions conventional wisdom
      Kathleen Long
      Plans enticing 401(k) savings even without employer contribution
      Joe Caldera
      Group acting to plug a gap in retirement
      Jean Young
      Analysis on stretching the match shows it doesn't work as intended
    • Ray Dalio book
      Dalio releases illustrated version of ‘Principles’ book
      Youngjae Ryu
      Korea Corporate Governance Forum set to debut Dec. 12
      MOney maze
      PLSA has tips for trustees of U.K. retirement funds
      Norm Champ
      Norm Champ shifts his focus to financial literacy in latest book
    • Macro hedge fund Stone Milliner shutting down
      James Medeiros
      Hedge fund managers are warming up to custom funds
      Louis Bacon
      Moore Capital's Louis Bacon to quit money management business
      James Yeh
      Citadel promotes James Yeh to president and co-CIO
    • CalPERS’ committee mulls new investment policies
      ESG worked in 2019, but questions remain for long term
      Wyoming investment board picks 2 for small-cap equities
      Pennsylvania Municipal Retirement looking for investment consultant
    • Mihir Worah
      PIMCO CIO for asset allocation and real assets to retire
      Icahn lays off workers as firm decamps to Miami
      Pacific Life hires head for new institutional arm
      1251 Capital acquires majority stake in Ziegler Capital
    • CalPERS’ committee mulls new investment policies
      Australian regulator lists underperforming funds
      PPF 7800 index funding deficit drops in November
      CDC, Laerernes commit to Amundi, EIB green bond program
    • Mihir Worah
      PIMCO CIO for asset allocation and real assets to retire
      OMERS Ventures picks Uber veteran
      Mercer appoints global alternatives leader for wealth business
      Apollo Global taps Bain Capital veteran to lead its Japan business
    • Parthenon Capital raises $2 billion with latest private equity fund
      Investindustrial raises €3.75 billion with seventh European buyout fund
      Sightway Capital closes first fund with $1.2 billion
      Private equity practices aired at House hearing
    • Schroders appoints real estate capital partners head
      CBRE acquires U.K. real estate debt investment business Laxfield Capital
      USAA to sell controlling interest in real estate unit
      Cold storage
      A hot time for those seeking the cold
    • Washington State Retirement hires Milliman as actuarial auditor
      Howard County allocates $7 million to venture capital
      Wisconsin deferred comp chooses Wilshire to analyze stable value options
      Illinois Teachers doles out $665 million to 5 alts managers
    • The best places to work in money management 2019
      Investment Consultants
      The 2019 Excellence & Innovation Awards
      Top-performing managers Q3 2019
  • Data
    • Research Center
    • Searches & Hires Database
    • Searches & Hires News
    • RFPs
    • Charts / Infographics
    • Sponsored Research
    • Trackers
    • Q3 2019 money manager M&A activity summary
      Q3 2019 legal overview report
      Q3 2019 searches and hires overview report
      P&I resources can give a leg up in winning new business
    • Washington State Retirement hires Milliman as actuarial auditor
      Howard County allocates $7 million to venture capital
      Wisconsin deferred comp chooses Wilshire to analyze stable value options
      Illinois Teachers doles out $665 million to 5 alts managers
    • Washington State Retirement hires Milliman as actuarial auditor
      Howard County allocates $7 million to venture capital
      Wisconsin deferred comp chooses Wilshire to analyze stable value options
      Illinois Teachers doles out $665 million to 5 alts managers
    • Transitional Manager Services
      457b DC PENSION PLAN
      Overlay and Passive Risk Balanced Investment Manager
      In-Kind Distribution Management Services (Private Markets) Provider Search
    • ESG worked in 2019, but questions remain for long term
      Latin America preparing for aging population
      To cheap large-caps go the spoils
      Only place to go is ... down
    • Institutional Investors: Shared Expectations, Divergent Paths
      Global Investor Study 2016
      Workplace Financial Wellness
    • U.S. Endowment Returns Tracker
      Pension Fund Returns Tracker
      Earnings Tracker
      Corporate Pension Contribution Tracker
  • Insights
    • Opinion
    • White Papers
    • Industry Voices
    • Other Views
    • Partner Content
    • Publisher's Update
    • Multiemployer fund legislation cartoon
      Multiemployer compromises needed
      SEC cartoon
      SEC rules need measured response
      High hopes for consistency and guidance from Scalia
      DC West poster
      Financial wellness gets spot at the table
    • Strengthen Your Core: Flexible Multi-Sector Strategies for a Low-Yield World
      WisdomTree Yield Enhanced U.S. Aggregate Bond Fund
      Automation, lower fees driving institutional interest in factor investing and smart beta strategies
      A Great Time to Be Agnostic?
    • Gerald Cooper
      Commentary: Single-asset deals – a structure benefiting GPs and LPs alike
      Gordon Latter, Timur Kaya Yontar and Frank Benham
      Commentary: Plan sponsors, do you know your credit risk?
      Timothy Boomer
      Commentary: For plan sponsors, derivatives shouldn’t be a dirty word
      Martin Vogt
      Commentary: Renewables investing makes inroads in the Caribbean, Central America
    • Commentary: Stronger partnership needed between shareholders, managers
      Commentary: Revised statement on corporate purpose misses the mark
      Commentary: The associated costs of DB terminations
      Commentary: Support the Butch Lewis Act
    • P&I Content Solutions
      EDHEC Research For Institutional Money Management - December 2019
      P&I Content Solutions
      Dynamic derisking: How an OCIO can help plan sponsors manage funding volatility
      P&I Content Solutions
      OCIO graduates from education phase
      P&I Content Solutions
      How to navigate the choppy investment waters expected in 2020
    • Everything Must Change
      Tomatoes & Investments
      Baby, it’s hot outside!
  • Multimedia
    • Videos
    • Webinars
    • Polls
    • Slideshows
    • Charts / Infographics
    • Excellence & Innovation Awards 2019: Laura Mittelstaedt
      DC West 2019
      Excellence & Innovation Awards 2019: Lisa Joe
      DC West 2019: Empower Retirement's Doug Peterson on cybersecurity
    • Finding the Positive in Negative Interest Rates
      How to Position Institutional Portfolios to Capitalize on China’s Growth
      Financial Wellness: Gaining an edge with plan sponsors
      Trends in Hedge Fund Investing
    • POLL: Creating a great workplace
      POLL: Shared values between money managers and plan sponsors
      POLL: Climate change's impact on investing
      POLL: Ultralong-term U.S. Treasury bonds
    • view gallery
      85 photos
      Best places to work in money management 2019
      view gallery
      21 photos
      The world's 20 largest retirement funds
      view gallery
      11 photos
      Top 10 DC money managers
      Top 15 managers by worldwide institutional AUM
    • ESG worked in 2019, but questions remain for long term
      Latin America preparing for aging population
  • Events
    • Conferences
    • Webinars
    • East Coast DC Conference
      Fixed Income & Credit
      DC Investment Lineup
      ESG Investing
    • Finding the Positive in Negative Interest Rates
      How to Position Institutional Portfolios to Capitalize on China’s Growth
      Financial Wellness: Gaining an edge with plan sponsors
      Trends in Hedge Fund Investing
  • Careers
  • Research Center
MENU
Breadcrumb
  1. Home
  2. ALTERNATIVES
April 15, 2019 01:00 AM

Benchmark quandary unresolved

Investors make changes to better reflect portfolios

Arleen Jacobius
  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Share
  • Email
  • More
    Reprints Print
    Meketa Investment Group's Allan Emkin

    Benchmarks for assessing the performance of private market assets leave much to be desired, industry insiders said, prompting institutional asset owners to tweak or even overhaul existing benchmarks to better reflect their evolving portfolios.

    "Of all of the illiquid markets, the only one with a reasonable benchmark currently is real estate," said Allan Emkin, Los Angeles-based managing principal at Meketa Investment Group Inc.

    "Here, (in real estate) there's a large number of open-end commingled funds that offer quarterly liquidity and — because of this — have their assets appraised frequently. There are abundant market comparables for most institutional properties," he said.

    Alternative investments are long-lived and for that reason are infrequently bought and sold, which makes them difficult to measure, industry insiders said. Investors do not really know the value of an investment until there is a transaction, they noted.

    The benchmark topic has become

    more urgent as capital continues to flow into the alternative investment asset classes. Alternative investment assets worldwide under management totaled $5.8 trillion as of June 30, an all-time high, up 12% from $5.2 trillion as of Dec. 31, 2017, and $2.3 billion as of Dec. 31, 2008, according to McKinsey & Co.'s private capital report released in February.

    While benchmarking for private equity is improving, it still has a long way to go, Mr. Emkin said. "Private market natural resources and infrastructure benchmarks, in particular, tend to be far less robust."

    Appraisals for certain unique assets such as airports are more challenging because they are priced less frequently, so it's harder to know what they're worth, he said.

    Making changes

    In the past 12 months, a number of asset owners have updated their benchmarks. Some institutional investors are accepting a lower premium over the public markets, others are changing the public market index and several are doing both.

    Count the $359.7 billion California Public Employees' Retirement System, Sacramento, the $226.5 billion California State Teachers' Retirement System, West Sacramento, and the $56.6 billion Los Angeles County Employees Retirement Association, Pasadena, Calif., as among the pension funds that have changed some of their benchmarks. And the $26.9 billion Texas Employees Retirement System, Austin, is in the midst of a benchmark overhaul. Pension plan officials expect to bring recommendations to the board at its May meeting, said Sharmila Kassam, deputy CIO of Texas ERS, California State Teachers' Retirement Systemn California State Teachers' Retirement System, West Sacramento, and the $56.6 billion Los Angeles County Employees Retirement Association, Pasadena, Calif., as among the pension funds that have changed someTexas Employees Retirement System.9 billion Texas Employees Retirement System, Austin, is in the midst of a benchmark overhaul. Pension plan officials expect to bring recommendations to the board at its May meeting, said Sharmila Kassam, deputy CIO of Texas ERS, in an email.

    NEPC LLC, the pension plan's investment consultant, is suggesting the board consider switching the private equity benchmark to Wilshire TUCS Peer Universe Benchmark from MSCI ACWI IMI plus 3%, which would change Texas ERS' benchmark to a peer-based index.

    "It's very complicated," said Steven Kaplan, the Neubauer Family Professor of Entrepreneurship and Finance at the University of Chicago Booth School of Business. The most difficult decision is the asset allocation mix choice. Then investors turn to questions of how the asset classes are performing, he said.

    Mr. Kaplan is the co-creator of the Kaplan-Schoar private market equivalent, which measures private equity performance compared with the S&P 500. Mr. Kaplan also assists and advises investment bank Lincoln International LLC on its Lincoln Middle Market (private equity) index.

    Private equity is one of the easiest of the private asset classes asset classes to measure due to public market comparisons, he said.

    "If you're not beating public equity, then why are you doing it?" Mr. Kaplan said. Then the decisions come down to which public equity market index to choose, such as the S&P 500 or the Russell 2000 or the Russell 2000 Value.

    "On the buyout side, do you want to factor in leverage or not?" he said. On the other hand, it's harder to choose a benchmark for credit because "there is not a lot of data."

    For example, should an investor select an equity index because credit investors are likely taking the same risk as stocks or a bond index because investors are getting the same maturities?

    CalSTRS has two private equity benchmarks for its $20.1 billion private equity portfolio: one long-term measure for strategic asset allocation and a short-term measure for implementation and compensation. The long-term benchmark is the Russell 3000 plus 300 basis points. The short-term benchmark is a custom State Street Global Exchange Private Equity index, measuring periods of 10 years or less.

    LACERA recently changed its private equity benchmark to a global public equity benchmark plus 200 basis points from a U.S. benchmark with a higher premium, said CIO Jonathan Grabel.

    "We believe this steers us to invest in the context of our portfolio as a whole, identify global opportunities and not to take excessive risk in the process," he said.

    Goals matter

    The best portfolio-level index is the one that aligns most closely with the goal of the portfolio, said TC Rolfstad, a vice president on the real assets team at alternative investment money manager and consultant Hamilton Lane Inc.

    "In certain areas (of real assets) it is well-defined, with industry-accepted indexes and methodologies, while elsewhere the industry is striving to catch up as new investment options crop up and plan sponsors evolve their portfolio structures and objectives," said Mr. Rolfstad, who is based in Portland, Ore.

    On March 28, for instance, CalSTRS modified its inflation-sensitive asset class benchmark to include the implementation of timber, agriculture and U.S. Treasury inflation-protected strategies. LACERA recently adopted new benchmarks for credit and real assets due to asset allocation changes.

    "As long as there is more than one fund in a category, there is some data to analyze performance on a relative basis. Obviously, the larger the data set, the more meaningful the analysis," Mr. Rolfstad said.

    While benchmarks for infrastructure credit and infrastructure equity "are thin," Mr. Rolfstad said that the industry is evolving. Real asset managers are starting to understand the value of sharing data, which will improve benchmarks, he said.

    Benchmarking private infrastructure as well as real estate held in closed-end funds has been a challenge due to the lack of transparency, said John Vojticek, Chicago-based head and chief investment officer of liquid real assets and co-head of equities in the U.S. at DWS Group.

    DWS recently launched a family of infrastructure debt indexes in collaboration with IHS Markit on the development of the Markit iBoxx infrastructure debt indexes. A subset of the iBoxx corporate debt indexes, they track listed infrastructure corporate bonds, excluding project bonds and private loans due to limited data availability and market size.

    There is not an equivalent for the NCREIF Open-End Diversified Core Equity index — a capitalization-weighted, gross of fee, time-weighted return index for real estate — for infrastructure, said Mark Roberts, New York-based head of research and strategy for alternatives and head of multiassets in the Americas for DWS. "I have index envy over what is available in the listed markets … The listed markets are way ahead of measuring performance."

    "There is not a lot of good data and history" in closed-end infrastructure as well as real estate funds, he said. Even in real estate, the benchmark world is evolving. On April 3, European real estate trade group INREV, the European Association for Investors in Non-Listed Real Estate, released the INREV European Open End Diversified Core Equity Fund index.

    "U.S. clients are very interested in that (new index)," Mr. Roberts said. "It's a major event."

    Investors' real estate portfolios are global and the new index "expands the market basket," he said.

    Before the new INREV index was released, investors could not get vacancy rates of certain property sectors in Europe, he said. Markets were informed by the prime survey of rents and yields of the top 5% of buildings in key locations in certain cities, Mr. Roberts explained.

    Credit concerns

    Aside from the leverage issue, private credit encompasses many strategies from senior loans and junior loans to investments holding companies in a variety geographies and investment sizes, industry executives say. These investments also vary in the amount of risk investors are taking. But most investors use a single benchmark for the asset class, they say.

    The best way to measure credit performance is to look at the investment's default and loss history, said David Brackett, the New York-based co-CEO and senior managing partner of credit manager Antares Capital LP. The firm is owned by the C$368.5 billion ($276 billion) Canada Pension Plan Investment Board, Toronto.

    Many asset owners use a benchmark that adds a premium to the public markets. For example, LACERA's illiquid credit benchmark is the Barclays Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate plus 250 basis points annualized.

    Private credit has been considered an asset class by investors for only five or six years, said Theodore L. Koenig, Chicago-based president and CEO of credit manager Monroe Capital LLC.

    "Before that we were a J-curve mitigant for private equity," Mr. Koenig said while speaking at a panel at the Pension Bridge Annual conference in San Francisco.

    Benchmarks continue to be a 300-basis-point to 400-basis-point premium over high yield, bank loans and Bloomberg Barclays aggregate indexes, he said in an interview. These benchmarks are designed to roughly estimate asset returns, he added.

    "There are no good indexes today," Mr. Koenig said. "More work has to be done."

    Peter E. Ehret, director of internal credit and high-yield portfolio manager at the Texas Employees Retirement System, said that benchmarking private credit is a "tough topic."

    Texas Employees officials look at the high-yield index, he said speaking on the panel with Mr. Koenig.

    "It's not perfect," he acknowledged but it's a well-developed index with a lot of information.

    Another panel participant, Greg Lippmann, partner and CIO of credit manager Libremax Capital LLC, said that trying to invest to a target return could cause managers to make investments they might not otherwise make because the manager is trying to hit the benchmark.

    "We are aware of a variety of metrics ... Trying to track them makes you a closet indexer," Mr. Lippmann said. "How you invest increases risk or mitigates risk."

    Related Articles
    Risk-parity strategies difficult to benchmark
    Risk-parity investors do a bit of second-guessing
    Leverage makes finding right benchmark harder
    IACPM: Near-term credit concerns abating
    Plymouth County reissues private equity RFP
    Newport News Employees picks Meketa as investment consultant
    Texas Employees to start search for global custodian in July
    Ohio Public Employees terminates $520 million emerging managers program
    Texas Employees targets $1.1 billion for private real estate, infrastructure
    Recommended for You
    sponsored content
    Events
     
     
    Advertisement
    White Papers
    A Great Time to Be Agnostic?
    Shedding the Home-Country Bias
    Automation, lower fees driving institutional interest in factor investing and s…
    WisdomTree Yield Enhanced U.S. Aggregate Bond Fund
    Strengthen Your Core: Flexible Multi-Sector Strategies for a Low-Yield World
    View More
    Sponsored Content
    Partner Content
    How Big Data Delivers Solutions to ESG Investors
    How a Multisector Credit Approach Can Lower Risk, Increase Diversification
    ESG Investing Supplement
    Know Your DB Plan’s ‘Persona’ to Help Make the Right Strategy Choices
    Leveling the playing field for public employee retirement security
    View More
    E-MAIL NEWSLETTERS

    Sign up and get the best of News delivered straight to your email inbox, free of charge. Choose your news – we will deliver.

    Subscribe Today

    Get access to the news, research and analysis of events affecting the retirement and institutional money management businesses from a worldwide network of reporters and editors.

    Subscribe
    Connect With Us
    • RSS
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn

    Our Mission

    To consistently deliver news, research and analysis to the executives who manage the flow of funds in the institutional investment market.

    pilogo-NEW
    About Us

    Main Office
    685 Third Avenue
    Tenth Floor
    New York, NY 10017-4036

    Chicago Office
    150 N. Michigan Ave.
    Chicago, IL 60601

    Contact Us

    About Pensions & Investments

     

    Advertising
    • Media Kit
    • P&I Content Solutions
    • P&I Careers | Post a Job
    • Reprints & Permissions
    Resources
    • Subscribe
    • Newsletters
    • FAQ
    • P&I Research Center
    • Site map
    • Staff Directory
    Legal
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions
    Pensions & Investments
    Copyright © 1996-2019. Crain Communications, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
    • NEWS
      • Alternatives
      • Consultants
      • Defined Contribution
      • Frontlines
      • Hedge Funds
      • Investing / Portfolio Strategies
      • Money Management
      • Pension Funds
      • People Moves
      • Private Equity
      • Real Estate
      • Searches & Hires News
      • Special Reports
    • Data
      • Research Center
      • Searches & Hires Database
      • Searches & Hires News
      • RFPs
      • Charts / Infographics
      • Sponsored Research
      • Trackers
    • Insights
      • Opinion
      • White Papers
      • Industry Voices
      • Other Views
      • Partner Content
      • Publisher's Update
    • Multimedia
      • Videos
      • Webinars
      • Polls
      • Slideshows
      • Charts / Infographics
    • Events
      • Conferences
      • Webinars
    • Careers
    • Research Center