Skip to main content
MENU
Subscribe
  • Subscribe
  • Account
  • LOGIN
  • Topics
    • Alternatives
    • Consultants
    • Coronavirus
    • Courts
    • Defined Contribution
    • ESG
    • ETFs
    • Hedge Funds
    • Industry Voices
    • Investing
    • Money Management
    • Opinion
    • Partner Content
    • Pension Funds
    • Private Equity
    • Real Estate
    • Russia-Ukraine War
    • SECURE Act 2.0
    • Special Reports
    • White Papers
  • Rankings & Awards
    • 1,000 Largest Retirement Plans
    • Top-Performing Managers
    • Largest Money Managers
    • DC Money Managers
    • DC Record Keepers
    • Largest Hedge Fund Managers
    • World's Largest Retirement Funds
    • Best Places to Work in Money Management
    • Excellence & Innovation Awards
    • Eddy Awards
  • ETFs
    • Latest ETF News
    • Fund Screener
    • Education Center
    • Equities
    • Fixed Income
    • Commodities
    • Actively Managed
    • Alternatives
    • ESG Rated
  • ESG
    • Latest ESG News
    • The Institutional Investor’s Guide to ESG Investing
    • Climate Change: The Inescapable Opportunity
    • Impact Investing
    • 2022 ESG Investing Conference
    • ESG Rated ETFs
  • Defined Contribution
    • Latest DC News
    • DC Money Manager Rankings
    • DC Record Keeper Rankings
    • Innovations in DC
    • Trends in DC: Focus on Retirement Income
    • 2022 Defined Contribution East Conference
    • 2022 DC Investment Lineup Conference
  • Searches & Hires
    • Latest Searches & Hires News
    • Searches & Hires Database
    • RFPs
  • Performance Data
    • P&I Research Center
    • Earnings Tracker
    • Endowment Returns Tracker
    • Corporate Pension Contribution Tracker
    • Pension Fund Returns Tracker
    • Pension Risk Transfer Database
    • Future of Investments Research Series
    • Charts & Infographics
    • Polls
  • Careers
  • Events
    • View All Conferences
    • View All Webinars
    • 2022 Innovation Investing Conference
    • 2022 Defined Contribution East Conference
    • 2022 ESG Investing Conference
    • 2022 DC Investment Lineup Conference
    • 2022 Alternatives Investing Conference
Breadcrumb
  1. Home
  2. COURTS
June 12, 2017 01:00 AM

More challenges promised despite church-plan victory

Hazel Bradford
  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Share
  • Email
  • More
    Reprints Print
    Liz Lynch
    Karen Ferguson sees a chance for litigation on issues the ruling didn't address.

    Sponsors of church-related pension plans are celebrating a Supreme Court decision upholding their right to be exempt from federal pension rules, but participant advocates vow to continue challenging them on other legal points and in new venues, including state courts.

    The unexpectedly unanimous Supreme Court decision June 5 brought a collective sigh of relief from religiously affiliated health-care systems that long have operated as exempt from the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, with its detailed rules on funding obligations, vesting, reporting, disclosure and more.

    Disagreeing with plan participants, who argued that there needed to be a direct church connection, the Supreme Court found pension plans did not have to be established by a church to be exempt from ERISA, as long as they are controlled by or associated with one.

    For the three health-care systems consolidated into the Supreme Court case, Dignity Health, Advocate Health Care and Saint Peter's Healthcare System, an opposite conclusion by the justices would have left the sponsors and other health-care systems in related cases staring at a combined $4 billion funding shortfall for roughly 300,000 plan participants.

    The Supreme Court's view of the matter, which was limited to interpreting what Congress intended when it created the exemption in 1980, is in sharp contrast to conclusions reached by three federal appellate courts in 2015 and 2016, upholding District Court rulings that only churches can set up church plans and disallowing the health systems' ERISA exemption. The trend of courts siding with plan participants led to several multimillion-dollar settlements in recent years, including the Franciscan Missionaries of Our Lady Health System, Baton Rouge, La., in May and from Providence Health & Services, Renton, Wash.; Saint Francis Hospital and Medical Center, Hartford, Conn.; and Trinity Health Corp., Livonia, Mich., all in 2016.

    A ‘ringing endorsement’

    In the Supreme Court opinion, Justice Elena Kagan wrote that a strict reading of the 1980 law that created the exemption allows it if a pension plan is set up for a “principal-purpose organization,” such as a board overseeing a benefit plan, that is associated with a church.

    The Supreme Court decision “is a ringing endorsement of the judicial precedent that has existed since 1980, and the regulatory pronouncements” from the IRS, Department of Labor and the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corp., all of which filed an amicus brief supporting the plan sponsors, said Howard Shapiro, a New Orleans attorney with Proskauer Rose who is defending many Catholic health-care entities in stayed class actions and who submitted a Supreme Court amicus brief on behalf of eight clients.

    “It is not often in our lifetime that we see a scenario like this,” he said.

    Pension plans run by church-affiliated organizations can choose to be covered by ERISA, but it's not required. Those not wanting ERISA coverage get an IRS private-letter ruling allowing the exemption, a practice that also has been challenged in many of the 100 or so participant class-action lawsuits against church-affiliated plans that have sprung up since 2013.

    Advocates for plan participants, devastated by the decision, say they now will focus on what the Supreme Court did not address.

    “The court did not decide whether the plans involved in the cases before it are maintained by the type of organization envisioned by Congress when it enacted the law,” said Karen Ferguson, director of the Pension Rights Center in Washington. Ms. Kagan's opinion held a footnote that the question of direct association with a church was not before the court.

    Vows to continue

    Plan participants will continue filing these cases “to ensure that the 'church plan' exemption is claimed only in appropriate circumstances,” promised Karen L. Handorf, partner at Cohen Milstein Sellers & Toll and co-counsel for many of the plaintiffs.

    “It's going to be a long road but we are optimistic,” said Ms. Ferguson. “It was only the first round. We are optimistic that the courts will realize that the only organizations intended by Congress were these church pension boards and that there is nothing in the legislative history that they intended to exempt a freestanding pension plan established by a hospital,” she added. She worries that the Supreme Court decision could wind up hurting millions of workers if other non-profits associated with churches, such as social services agencies and universities, also seek church-plan status.

    Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor raised that question in a concurring opinion. While the decision correctly interprets the statutory text, she wrote, “I am nonetheless troubled by the outcome of these cases,” which she said were spurred by the failure of unregulated church plans. “It is not at all clear that Congress would take the same action today with respect to some of the largest health-care providers in the country” that compete with companies subject to ERISA, she wrote.

    Answering those questions is likely to be the focus of the next wave of plaintiff lawsuits, which legal experts on both sides see taking place increasingly in state courts under laws covering contractual promises, fiduciary standards and the right to bring claims, all of which would not be preempted by ERISA.

    “There are a lot of other things that are often significant. Those questions were not before the court and the court did not answer them,” said Ronald Cluett, of counsel to tax law firm Caplin & Drysdale in Washington, who specializes in employee benefits compliance. “I think that the people who did not prevail will seek other ways,” including scrutinizing how closely plan sponsors are affiliated with churches, and how the benefits committees are structured, he said.

    Brian Netter, co-leader of law firm Mayer Brown's Supreme Court and appellate practice in Washington, agreed. “Participants will have to be a lot more careful of how they connect these hospital plans to ERISA, and most will not succeed. Whenever one door closes another window somewhere opens up. There's too much for people to give up,” he said.

    Mr. Shapiro of Proskauer Rose also expects plan participants and their lawyers to continue to put pressure on church plan sponsors, but he said the Supreme Court ruling “very much strengthens the positions of the church-plan community. It will give the (plan sponsor) defendants an upper hand.”

    Related Articles
    Holy Cross Hospital agrees to $9.1 million settlement in church-plan challenge
    Franciscan Missionaries of Our Lady Health System settles church-plan lawsuit
    Supreme Court unanimously backs ERISA exemptions for church plans
    Ascension, Wheaton Franciscan settle church-plan challenge
    Appeals court upholds dismissal of church-plan challenge
    Commentary: 5 questions church pension plan sponsors should ask to avoid legal …
    Lawsuits allege fraud, conspiracy in insolvency of St. Joseph Health Services o…
    Recommended for You
    ONLINE_180709926_AR_0_SPVGDZVTUNPE.jpg
    Barnabas Health settles ERISA complaint for $1.75 million
    The Goldman Sachs & Co. logo is displayed at the company's booth on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange on July 19, 2013
    Goldman Sachs agrees to $79.5 million settlement on 1MDB lawsuit
    ONLINE_180539987_AR_0_AJVEYGQPKZAX.jpg
    Nextep, former participants reach deal to settle ERISA lawsuit
    OCIO, Anchor in Rough Seas
    Sponsored Content: OCIO, Anchor in Rough Seas

    Reader Poll

    May 9, 2022
    SEE MORE POLLS >
    Sponsored
    White Papers
    Are Factors a Thing of the Past?
    Q2 2022 Credit Outlook: Carry On
    Leverage does not equal risk
    Is there a mid-cap gap in your DC plan?
    Out of the Shadows: The Revolution in Shadow Accounting
    The pivotal role of fixed income markets in the ESG revolution
    View More
    Sponsored Content
    Partner Content
    The Industrialization of ESG Investment
    For institutional investors, ETFs can make meeting liquidity needs easier
    Gold: the most effective commodity investment
    2021 Investment Outlook | Investing Beyond the Pandemic: A Reset for Portfolios
    Ten ways retirement plan professionals add value to plan sponsors
    Gold: an efficient hedge
    View More
    E-MAIL NEWSLETTERS

    Sign up and get the best of News delivered straight to your email inbox, free of charge. Choose your news – we will deliver.

    Subscribe Today
    May 9, 2022 page one

    Get access to the news, research and analysis of events affecting the retirement and institutional money management businesses from a worldwide network of reporters and editors.

    Subscribe
    Connect With Us
    • RSS
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn

    Our Mission

    To consistently deliver news, research and analysis to the executives who manage the flow of funds in the institutional investment market.

    About Us

    Main Office
    685 Third Avenue
    Tenth Floor
    New York, NY 10017-4036

    Chicago Office
    130 E. Randolph St.
    Suite 3200
    Chicago, IL 60601

    Contact Us

    Careers at Crain

    About Pensions & Investments

     

    Advertising
    • Media Kit
    • P&I Content Solutions
    • P&I Careers | Post a Job
    • Reprints & Permissions
    Resources
    • Subscribe
    • Newsletters
    • FAQ
    • P&I Research Center
    • Site map
    • Staff Directory
    Legal
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Request
    Pensions & Investments
    Copyright © 1996-2022. Crain Communications, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
    • Topics
      • Alternatives
      • Consultants
      • Coronavirus
      • Courts
      • Defined Contribution
      • ESG
      • ETFs
      • Hedge Funds
      • Industry Voices
      • Investing
      • Money Management
      • Opinion
      • Partner Content
      • Pension Funds
      • Private Equity
      • Real Estate
      • Russia-Ukraine War
      • SECURE Act 2.0
      • Special Reports
      • White Papers
    • Rankings & Awards
      • 1,000 Largest Retirement Plans
      • Top-Performing Managers
      • Largest Money Managers
      • DC Money Managers
      • DC Record Keepers
      • Largest Hedge Fund Managers
      • World's Largest Retirement Funds
      • Best Places to Work in Money Management
      • Excellence & Innovation Awards
      • Eddy Awards
    • ETFs
      • Latest ETF News
      • Fund Screener
      • Education Center
      • Equities
      • Fixed Income
      • Commodities
      • Actively Managed
      • Alternatives
      • ESG Rated
    • ESG
      • Latest ESG News
      • The Institutional Investor’s Guide to ESG Investing
      • Climate Change: The Inescapable Opportunity
      • Impact Investing
      • 2022 ESG Investing Conference
      • ESG Rated ETFs
    • Defined Contribution
      • Latest DC News
      • DC Money Manager Rankings
      • DC Record Keeper Rankings
      • Innovations in DC
      • Trends in DC: Focus on Retirement Income
      • 2022 Defined Contribution East Conference
      • 2022 DC Investment Lineup Conference
    • Searches & Hires
      • Latest Searches & Hires News
      • Searches & Hires Database
      • RFPs
    • Performance Data
      • P&I Research Center
      • Earnings Tracker
      • Endowment Returns Tracker
      • Corporate Pension Contribution Tracker
      • Pension Fund Returns Tracker
      • Pension Risk Transfer Database
      • Future of Investments Research Series
      • Charts & Infographics
      • Polls
    • Careers
    • Events
      • View All Conferences
      • View All Webinars
      • 2022 Innovation Investing Conference
      • 2022 Defined Contribution East Conference
      • 2022 ESG Investing Conference
      • 2022 DC Investment Lineup Conference
      • 2022 Alternatives Investing Conference