Skip to main content
MENU
Subscribe
  • Sign Up Free
  • LOGIN
  • Subscribe
  • Topics
    • Alternatives
    • Artificial Intelligence
    • Consultants
    • Defined Contribution
    • ESG
    • ETFs
    • Face to Face
    • Hedge Funds
    • Industry Voices
    • Investing
    • Money Management
    • Partner Content
    • Pension Funds
    • Private Equity
    • Real Estate
    • Regulation
    • SECURE 2.0
    • Special Reports
    • Washington
    • White Papers
  • Rankings & Awards
    • 1,000 Largest Retirement Plans
    • Top-Performing Managers
    • Largest Money Managers
    • DC Money Managers
    • DC Record Keepers
    • Largest Hedge Fund Managers
    • World's Largest Retirement Funds
    • Best Places to Work in Money Management
    • Excellence & Innovation Awards
    • WPS Innovation Awards
    • Influential Women in Institutional Investing 2023
    • Eddy Awards
  • ETFs
    • Latest ETF News
    • Fund Screener
    • Education Center
    • Equities
    • Fixed Income
    • Commodities
    • Actively Managed
    • Alternatives
    • ESG Rated
  • ESG
    • Latest ESG News
    • The Institutional Investor’s Guide to ESG Investing
    • ESG Sustainability - Gaining Momentum
    • ESG Investing | Industry Brief
    • Innovation in ESG Investing
    • 2023 ESG Investing Conference
    • ESG Rated ETFs
    • Divestment Database
  • Defined Contribution
    • Latest DC News
    • The Plan Sponsor's Guide to Retirement Income
    • DC Money Manager Rankings
    • DC Record Keeper Rankings
    • Innovations in DC
    • DC Plan Design: Improving Participant Outcomes
    • 2023 Defined Contribution East Conference
  • Searches & Hires
    • Latest Searches & Hires News
    • Searches & Hires Database
    • RFPs
  • Research Center
    • The P&I Research Center
    • Earnings Tracker
    • Endowment Returns Tracker
    • Corporate Pension Contribution Tracker
    • Pension Fund Returns Tracker
    • Pension Risk Transfer Database
  • Careers
  • Events
    • View All Conferences
    • View All Webinars
Breadcrumb
  1. Home
  2. COURTS
July 07, 2014 01:00 AM

End of prudence presumption raising employer stock questions

Robert Steyer
  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Share
  • Email
  • More
    Reprints Print
    David Toerge
    Lori Lucas said the court case could discourage plans from offering company stock.

    The U.S. Supreme Court ruling in Fifth Third Bancorp. et al. vs. Dudenhoeffer et al. has injected uncertainty into defined contribution plans' use of employer stock in investment menus.

    The court ruled that employee stock ownership plans have no special presumption of prudence in offering employer stock, erasing a 19-year legal principle — called the Moench presumption — that many plans had used as a defense in participant lawsuits that claimed a breach of fiduciary duty when company stock prices fell.

    However, the court also provided guidelines for lower courts to assess whether such stock-drop complaints were sufficient to merit a trial. These guidelines discuss plan fiduciaries' responsibilities relating to public information about stocks, insider information, securities laws and plausible alternative actions in the face of a falling stock price.

    The ruling's impact goes beyond ESOPs.

    “The decision governs qualified retirement plans that are governed by ERISA that offer company stock of the employer, whether publicly traded or closely held, regardless of the plan design,” said Thomas E. Clark Jr., a partner with The Lowenbaum Partnership LLC, St. Louis, and outside ERISA counsel to FRA PlanTools LLC, a fiduciary consulting firm.

    DC consultants, attorneys and trade group representatives say the ruling will encourage more plan executives to review how they administer and monitor company stock within DC plans — or question if they want to add company stock to their investment menu. They said it is too early to determine if the decision will lead to more lawsuits or settlements.

    “There's a lot of sorting out to do,” said Lori Lucas, the Chicago-based executive vice president and defined contribution practice leader at Callan Associates Inc.

    Fifth Third Bancorp, a publicly traded company that offers participants a 401(k) plan with many investment options, one of which is company stock via an ESOP. The participants sued, saying fiduciaries breached their duties by failing to act when the company stock price fell 74% between July 2007 and September 2009.

    In the 9-0 decision, Justice Stephen Breyer wrote that “ESOP fiduciaries are subject to the same duty of prudence that applies to ERISA fiduciaries in general, except that they need not diversify the (ESOP) fund's assets.”

    Instead of relying on the “defense-friendly” presumption of prudence, courts should evaluate stock-drop cases “through careful, context-sensitive scrutiny of a complaint's allegations,” Mr. Breyer wrote.

    The Department of Labor hailed the ruling that overturned the presumption of prudence standard established in 1995 by the 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals, Philadelphia, in Moench vs. Robertson. “The Supreme Court's decision will restore the ability of ESOP participants to have their day in court when plan trustees overpay for company stock,” Deborah Greenfield, deputy solicitor of labor, wrote in the DOL's blog June 27.

    Although the presumption of prudence “was a reasonable tool” for courts to assess the validity of stock-drop lawsuits early, the new guidelines appear to offer protection against meritless lawsuits, said Scott Macey, president and CEO of the ERISA Industry Committee, Washington. If he were a DC plan executive, Mr. Macey said, “I wouldn't take any precipitous action.”

    If DC plans don't have company-stock in their investment lineups now, he added, “I doubt they'll consider adding it” given the uncertainty of how courts will interpret the Supreme Court's decision.

    “It's very challenging” to eliminate company stock from an investment menu under any circumstances because sponsors fear participants might think there's something wrong with the company, said Callan's Ms. Lucas.

    Be careful

    As for plans contemplating adding company stock, “I tell clients: "Don't do something that will be difficult to unwind,'” Ms. Lucas said. If there's extra oversight due to the Fifth Third Bancorp case, “that could discourage sponsors from adding company stock” to the investment lineup, she said.

    A Callan survey of DC executives, issued in January, reported that 16% would eliminate company stock as an option this year, “a notable increase from prior years,” said a report on the survey.

    The Supreme Court's ruling will require greater vigilance among DC plan sponsors, said Robyn Credico, Arlington, Va.-based defined contribution practice leader for Towers Watson & Co. “If you have company stock in the plan, you need to monitor it like any regular investment because it's not protected by the presumption of prudence anymore,” she said.

    Even before the ruling, Ms. Credico was advising clients against adding company stock to their investment lineups over concerns about having adequate diversification. “Now, you have more potential of fiduciary risk,” she said.

    The decision also might encourage more DC plan executives to examine steps already taken by some peers to reduce fiduciary risk. “Now, you have to prove your prudence,” said Marcia Wagner, an ERISA law specialist and managing director of the Wagner Law Group, Boston. The Supreme Court's ruling will require plan officials to “increase their knowledge that procedural and substantive prudence is important in menu selection.”

    One possible strategy for companies is to assign management of the employer-stock option to an independent fiduciary. In Callan's survey of DC plan executives, 19.2% said they outsourced oversight of company stock to limit potential liability.

    “I suspect a good number of fiduciaries will consider this option if they hadn't considered it before,” said Jeremy Blumenfeld, a Philadelphia-based partner with Morgan, Lewis & Bockius LLP who represents companies in ERISA cases. One drawback is that this approach raises costs.

    Another consideration for DC plans is that independent fiduciaries might be less aware of the “big picture” — corporate culture and employee demographics — than in-house managers, he said.

    Another possible strategy is to remove insiders, such as the chief financial officer or CEO, from the committee overseeing company stock. In the Callan survey, 15.4% of executives cited this strategy to reduce liability. “I would not be surprised if more of those discussions will occur,” said Ms. Lucas.

    Insulating top executives from company-stock investing “reduces the chance of having non-public information” affecting decisions, Mr. Blumenfeld said.

    He added that the end of the Moench presumption will put pressure on the plans that have used the “hard-wire defense” to limit liability. Many plans — 38.5% according to the Callan survey — write into their plan documents, or hard-wire them, that company stock is required as an option.

    “Hard-wiring isn't going to be the bullet-proof approach that some folks thought it would be,” thanks to the Supreme Court ruling, said James P. McElligott Jr., a Richmond, Va.-based partner with McGuireWoods LLP, who represents companies with DC plans.

    In the Supreme Court ruling, Mr. Breyer wrote: “The duty of prudence trumps the instructions of a plan document, such as an instruction to invest exclusively in employer stock even if financial goals demand the contrary. ... This rule would make little sense if, as petitioners argue, the duty of prudence is defined by the aims of the particular plan as set out in the plan documents, since in that case the duty of prudence could never conflict with a plan document.”

    The Fifth Third Bancorp decision “is a mixed bag,” said Mr. Clark, of The Lowenbaum Partnership, as it tried to balance federal laws that encourage the use of ESOPs with laws that demand prudence of fiduciaries. Although fiduciaries lost a big weapon against stock-drop suits, it will take time for lower courts to interpret the new standards about whether stock-drop complaints should go to trial, Mr. Clark said. “Some plaintiffs and defendants may wind up in the Supreme Court again,” he said.

    Related Articles
    Precedent is upheld on class-action lawsuits that are spurred by stock losses
    High court seen likely to take ERISA fidicuary-breach case
    Supreme Court declines stock-drop case
    Fiduciary breach issue gets Supreme Court hearing
    GAO: Collective trading activity by 401(k) participants not 'significant concer…
    Recommended for You
    Marsh_McLennan_1550_i.jpg
    Judge tosses 401(k) suit against Marsh & McLennan over BlackRock TDFs
    grocery store aisle full 1550_i.jpg
    Southeastern Grocers sued over 401(k) plan fees
    ONLINE_190109864_AR_0_SLHVICTSVYPI.jpg
    NextEra Energy hit with lawsuit over 401(k) fees
    DC Plan Design: Improving Participant Outcomes
    Sponsored Content: DC Plan Design: Improving Participant Outcomes
    Sponsored
    White Papers
    Exploring the Commercial Application of Artificial Intelligence
    Conflict Minerals: The human cost of our electronics
    Research for Institutional Money Management
    Private real estate entry points emerging amid selloff
    2023 Hot Topics in Retirement and Financial Wellbeing
    Bonds: Shaken, but Not Stirred
    View More
    Sponsored Content
    Partner Content
    The Industrialization of ESG Investment
    For institutional investors, ETFs can make meeting liquidity needs easier
    Gold: the most effective commodity investment
    2021 Investment Outlook | Investing Beyond the Pandemic: A Reset for Portfolios
    Ten ways retirement plan professionals add value to plan sponsors
    Gold: an efficient hedge
    View More
    E-MAIL NEWSLETTERS

    Sign up and get the best of News delivered straight to your email inbox, free of charge. Choose your news – we will deliver.

    Subscribe Today
    December 12, 2022 page one

    Get access to the news, research and analysis of events affecting the retirement and institutional money management businesses from a worldwide network of reporters and editors.

    Subscribe
    Connect With Us
    • RSS
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn

    Our Mission

    To consistently deliver news, research and analysis to the executives who manage the flow of funds in the institutional investment market.

    About Us

    Main Office
    685 Third Avenue
    Tenth Floor
    New York, NY 10017-4036

    Chicago Office
    130 E. Randolph St.
    Suite 3200
    Chicago, IL 60601

    Contact Us

    Careers at Crain

    About Pensions & Investments

     

    Advertising
    • Media Kit
    • P&I Custom Content
    • P&I Careers | Post a Job
    • Reprints & Permissions
    Resources
    • Subscribe
    • Newsletters
    • FAQ
    • P&I Research Center
    • Site map
    • Staff Directory
    Legal
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Request
    Pensions & Investments
    Copyright © 1996-2023. Crain Communications, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
    • Topics
      • Alternatives
      • Artificial Intelligence
      • Consultants
      • Defined Contribution
      • ESG
      • ETFs
      • Face to Face
      • Hedge Funds
      • Industry Voices
      • Investing
      • Money Management
      • Partner Content
      • Pension Funds
      • Private Equity
      • Real Estate
      • Regulation
      • SECURE 2.0
      • Special Reports
      • Washington
      • White Papers
    • Rankings & Awards
      • 1,000 Largest Retirement Plans
      • Top-Performing Managers
      • Largest Money Managers
      • DC Money Managers
      • DC Record Keepers
      • Largest Hedge Fund Managers
      • World's Largest Retirement Funds
      • Best Places to Work in Money Management
      • Excellence & Innovation Awards
      • WPS Innovation Awards
      • Influential Women in Institutional Investing 2023
      • Eddy Awards
    • ETFs
      • Latest ETF News
      • Fund Screener
      • Education Center
      • Equities
      • Fixed Income
      • Commodities
      • Actively Managed
      • Alternatives
      • ESG Rated
    • ESG
      • Latest ESG News
      • The Institutional Investor’s Guide to ESG Investing
      • ESG Sustainability - Gaining Momentum
      • ESG Investing | Industry Brief
      • Innovation in ESG Investing
      • 2023 ESG Investing Conference
      • ESG Rated ETFs
      • Divestment Database
    • Defined Contribution
      • Latest DC News
      • The Plan Sponsor's Guide to Retirement Income
      • DC Money Manager Rankings
      • DC Record Keeper Rankings
      • Innovations in DC
      • DC Plan Design: Improving Participant Outcomes
      • 2023 Defined Contribution East Conference
    • Searches & Hires
      • Latest Searches & Hires News
      • Searches & Hires Database
      • RFPs
    • Research Center
      • The P&I Research Center
      • Earnings Tracker
      • Endowment Returns Tracker
      • Corporate Pension Contribution Tracker
      • Pension Fund Returns Tracker
      • Pension Risk Transfer Database
    • Careers
    • Events
      • View All Conferences
      • View All Webinars