Skip to main content
MENU
Subscribe
  • Subscribe
  • Account
  • LOGIN
  • Topics
    • Alternatives
    • Consultants
    • Coronavirus
    • Courts
    • Defined Contribution
    • ESG
    • ETFs
    • Hedge Funds
    • Industry Voices
    • Investing
    • Money Management
    • Opinion
    • Partner Content
    • Pension Funds
    • Private Equity
    • Real Estate
    • Russia-Ukraine War
    • SECURE Act 2.0
    • Special Reports
    • White Papers
  • Rankings & Awards
    • 1,000 Largest Retirement Plans
    • Top-Performing Managers
    • Largest Money Managers
    • DC Money Managers
    • DC Record Keepers
    • Largest Hedge Fund Managers
    • World's Largest Retirement Funds
    • Best Places to Work in Money Management
    • Excellence & Innovation Awards
    • WPS Innovation Awards
    • Eddy Awards
  • ETFs
    • Latest ETF News
    • Fund Screener
    • Education Center
    • Equities
    • Fixed Income
    • Commodities
    • Actively Managed
    • Alternatives
    • ESG Rated
  • ESG
    • Latest ESG News
    • The Institutional Investor’s Guide to ESG Investing
    • ESG Sustainability - Gaining Momentum
    • Climate Change: The Inescapable Opportunity
    • Impact Investing
    • 2022 ESG Investing Conference
    • ESG Rated ETFs
  • Defined Contribution
    • Latest DC News
    • DC Money Manager Rankings
    • DC Record Keeper Rankings
    • Innovations in DC
    • Trends in DC: Focus on Retirement Income
    • 2022 Defined Contribution East Conference
    • 2022 DC Investment Lineup Conference
  • Searches & Hires
    • Latest Searches & Hires News
    • Searches & Hires Database
    • RFPs
  • Performance Data
    • P&I Research Center
    • Earnings Tracker
    • Endowment Returns Tracker
    • Corporate Pension Contribution Tracker
    • Pension Fund Returns Tracker
    • Pension Risk Transfer Database
    • Future of Investments Research Series
    • Charts & Infographics
    • Polls
  • Careers
  • Events
    • View All Conferences
    • View All Webinars
    • 2022 Retirement Income Conference
    • 2022 Managing Pension Risk & Liabilities
    • 2022 WorldPensionSummit
Breadcrumb
  1. Home
  2. ASSET OWNERS
June 09, 2014 01:00 AM

Using tontines to solve public pension underfunding

Jonathan B. Forman and Michael J. Sabin
  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Share
  • Email
  • More
    Reprints Print

    Tontines are investment vehicles that could replace large pension plans, public or private, or those of smaller employers, and could be used to provide retirement income for participants.

    These “tontine pensions” would have several major advantages over most of today's pension programs, especially with the challenge of maintaining full funding.

    In a simple tontine, a group of investors pool their money to buy a portfolio of investments, and, as investors die, their shares are forfeited, with the entire amount going to the last surviving investor. On the television show “M*A*S*H” for example, Col. Sherman T. Potter, as the last survivor of his World War I unit, got to open the bottle of French cognac he and his buddies had bought. Over the years, this last-survivor-takes-all approach has made for some great fiction where nefarious characters try to kill off the rest of the investors and “inherit” the fund.

    Of course, tontines can be designed to avoid such mischief. For example, a tontine could be designed to make periodic distributions to surviving investors and to solicit new investors to replace those that have died. Structured in this way, a tontine could operate into perpetuity; and it could be used to create a fully funded tontine pension.

    In a tontine that makes periodic distributions, forfeitures might be divided equally among the survivors. For example, four people might each contribute $1,000 to a tontine, and when one dies, each survivor would get $333.33. Unfortunately, this simple approach can be unfair — for example, because it favors younger investors who are likely to live longer and so receive more distributions.

    Instead, distributions should be made in unequal portions, carefully chosen to provide fair bets for all investors. For example, imagine that our four $1,000 investors are age 65, 70, 75 and 80. According to the Social Security Administration's 2009 unisex life expectancy table, our 65-year-old has an 18.88-year life expectancy and a 1.3% probability of dying before reaching age 66; our 70-year-old has a 15.22-year life expectancy and a 2% death probability; our 75-year-old has an 11.89-year life expectancy and a 3.2% death probability; and our 80-year-old participant has an 8.95-year life expectancy and a 5.2% death probability.

    With some elementary mathematics, we can use these death probabilities to determine a fair way to divide any dying member's $1,000 investment among the survivors. For example, if the 80-year-old participant is the first to die, the 65-year-old should get $187.64, the 70-year-old should get $300.51, and the 75-year-old should get $511.85. The younger investors should get less as they are likely to live longer and so receive more distributions.

    Tontines can also be designed to take into account differing levels of contributions and to properly account for investment earnings. Certainly, those who survive the longest would get better than average returns, while those who die young might not even recover their initial investments. On average, however, each investor could expect to recover their initial contribution and any returns on that investment. In short, this tontine provides a fair bet.

    Two more enhancements are needed to create a tontine pension plan. First, in order to provide regular rather than sporadic distributions, we will need more investors. For example, with 5,000 investors, survivors could pretty much count on getting some money every month. Also, rather than making distributions whenever a member dies, we should just make monthly distributions. If a member is alive at the end of the month, he or she will get a share of the forfeitures from those who died that month. If a participant dies during the month, they will get nothing, as the balance in their account was distributed to the remaining survivors.

    Second, in order to provide level distributions throughout retirement, we need to cancel out the age-related back-loading inherent in a fair tontine. For example, that is what occurred when the 80-year-old in our four-investor example died: The 75-year-old survivor got $511.85, but the 65-year-old survivor got just $187.64.

    Our approach is to use a “self-payback” mechanism that increases the distributions made to younger survivors and decreases the distributions to older survivors. Basically, if a retiree is alive at the end of the month, they get a distribution equal to the balance in his or her tontine account divided by the appropriate monthly annuity factor. For example, if an employee retired at age 65 with $100,000 in a tontine pension, we estimate they would get level distributions of around $850 a month for life ($10,000 a year).

    Alternatively, a tontine pension could be designed to make inflation-adjusted distributions to retirees. Assuming a 3% inflation rate, our hypothetical 65-year-old retiree would get around $660 in the month she retired, but eventually her inflation-adjusted distributions would exceed the $850-a-month distributions of the level tontine pension.

    Now, assume a large employer decides to contribute 10% of salary to a tontine pension plan for all of its employees. Consider an employee who started working for that employer at age 35 and retired at age 65. We estimate that he would earn a level tontine pension that would initially replace around 55% of final earnings or, alternatively, an inflation-adjusted tontine pension that would replace around 43% of final earnings.


    As in a defined contribution plan, participants could be allowed to direct the investment of their individual accounts, but we believe the sponsor of a tontine pension plan would do a better job. Unlike a defined contribution plan, however, there would be no option for lump-sum payouts: Benefits would be paid out only as monthly distributions that would closely resemble the monthly payments from an actuarially fair variable annuity. As with both defined contribution plans and variable annuities, monthly tontine pension distributions would fluctuate with the value of the underlying investments, although that variability could be reduced by designing the plan to smooth distributions over, say two or three years, and, in any event, individuals can always self-budget to smooth their consumption in the face of variable income.

    We acknowledge plan sponsors might face some challenges in explaining how tontine pensions actually work. From a participant's standpoint, however, a tontine pension would look like a variable annuity, and a “smoothed” tontine pension would look like a traditional defined benefit pension or fixed annuity.

    All in all, tontine pension plans would have three major advantages over today's pension programs. First, unlike traditional pension plans — which are frequently underfunded, tontine pension plans would always be fully funded, just as defined contribution plans are funded, through regular contributions equal to, say, 10% of salary. This fully funded feature should make tontine pension programs particularly attractive to public and private employers with underfunded pension funds. While replacing a traditional pension plan with a tontine pension plan would do nothing to reduce the plan's unfunded liability, the sponsor would never again have to worry about underfunding attributable to future benefit accruals.

    Second, unlike traditional pensions — where the plan sponsor must bear all the investment and actuarial risks, with a tontine pension the plan sponsor would bear neither of those risks, as both are implicitly passed on to the participants.

    Finally, tontine pension plans would be inexpensive to operate. The underlying investments could be managed by a cadre of active and passive investment managers, just as they are in a defined benefit or defined contribution plan. But, unlike a DB plan, no actuary would be needed, as monthly distributions would automatically approximate an actuarially fair variable annuity. Also, unlike a commercial annuity, no money would need to be set aside for insurance company reserves and profits. In fact, we believe a discount stock broker could manage a tontine pension plan for as little as 0.3% of assets under management (e.g., 0.1% for a passive stock index fund and another 0.2% for the tontine pension management and record-keeping functions); and that means tontine pension plans would be able to provide significantly higher lifetime income benefits to retirees than current pension plans or annuities.


    Jonathan B. Forman is the Alfred P. Murrah professor of law at the University of Oklahoma, Norman, and Michael J. Sabin is an independent consultant in Sunnyvale, Calif. They are the authors of “Tontine Pensions: A Solution to the State and Local Pension Underfunding Crisis,” forthcoming in the University of Pennsylvania Law Review.

    Related Articles
    Using survivor funds to boost 401(k) returns
    Recommended for You
    ONLINE_190329864_AR_0_YBKZZQSSKIZH.jpg
    IMCO returns 9.6% in 2021, outperforming its benchmark
    SLIDESHOW2_824009999_PH_7_HOEACWCAWVKF.jpg
    Northern Trust plan universe returns 0.2% in Q3
    Northern Trust: Institutional asset owners post 6% gain in Q2
    Northern Trust: Institutional asset owners post 6% gain in Q2
    Private Markets
    Sponsored Content: Private Markets

    Reader Poll

    August 10, 2022
    SEE MORE POLLS >
    Sponsored
    White Papers
    Gaining Momentum: Where Next for Trend-Following?
    The market opportunity in U.S. residential mortgage-backed securities
    Credit Indices Evolve with Enhanced Data Inputs
    Hedge Funds 2.0: Back to the future
    How Has 2022's Carnage Reshaped Global Stock and Bond Markets?
    Crossroads: Politics, Inflation, & Bonds
    View More
    Sponsored Content
    Partner Content
    The Industrialization of ESG Investment
    For institutional investors, ETFs can make meeting liquidity needs easier
    Gold: the most effective commodity investment
    2021 Investment Outlook | Investing Beyond the Pandemic: A Reset for Portfolios
    Ten ways retirement plan professionals add value to plan sponsors
    Gold: an efficient hedge
    View More
    E-MAIL NEWSLETTERS

    Sign up and get the best of News delivered straight to your email inbox, free of charge. Choose your news – we will deliver.

    Subscribe Today
    August 1, 2022 page one

    Get access to the news, research and analysis of events affecting the retirement and institutional money management businesses from a worldwide network of reporters and editors.

    Subscribe
    Connect With Us
    • RSS
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn

    Our Mission

    To consistently deliver news, research and analysis to the executives who manage the flow of funds in the institutional investment market.

    About Us

    Main Office
    685 Third Avenue
    Tenth Floor
    New York, NY 10017-4036

    Chicago Office
    130 E. Randolph St.
    Suite 3200
    Chicago, IL 60601

    Contact Us

    Careers at Crain

    About Pensions & Investments

     

    Advertising
    • Media Kit
    • P&I Content Solutions
    • P&I Careers | Post a Job
    • Reprints & Permissions
    Resources
    • Subscribe
    • Newsletters
    • FAQ
    • P&I Research Center
    • Site map
    • Staff Directory
    Legal
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Request
    Pensions & Investments
    Copyright © 1996-2022. Crain Communications, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
    • Topics
      • Alternatives
      • Consultants
      • Coronavirus
      • Courts
      • Defined Contribution
      • ESG
      • ETFs
      • Hedge Funds
      • Industry Voices
      • Investing
      • Money Management
      • Opinion
      • Partner Content
      • Pension Funds
      • Private Equity
      • Real Estate
      • Russia-Ukraine War
      • SECURE Act 2.0
      • Special Reports
      • White Papers
    • Rankings & Awards
      • 1,000 Largest Retirement Plans
      • Top-Performing Managers
      • Largest Money Managers
      • DC Money Managers
      • DC Record Keepers
      • Largest Hedge Fund Managers
      • World's Largest Retirement Funds
      • Best Places to Work in Money Management
      • Excellence & Innovation Awards
      • WPS Innovation Awards
      • Eddy Awards
    • ETFs
      • Latest ETF News
      • Fund Screener
      • Education Center
      • Equities
      • Fixed Income
      • Commodities
      • Actively Managed
      • Alternatives
      • ESG Rated
    • ESG
      • Latest ESG News
      • The Institutional Investor’s Guide to ESG Investing
      • ESG Sustainability - Gaining Momentum
      • Climate Change: The Inescapable Opportunity
      • Impact Investing
      • 2022 ESG Investing Conference
      • ESG Rated ETFs
    • Defined Contribution
      • Latest DC News
      • DC Money Manager Rankings
      • DC Record Keeper Rankings
      • Innovations in DC
      • Trends in DC: Focus on Retirement Income
      • 2022 Defined Contribution East Conference
      • 2022 DC Investment Lineup Conference
    • Searches & Hires
      • Latest Searches & Hires News
      • Searches & Hires Database
      • RFPs
    • Performance Data
      • P&I Research Center
      • Earnings Tracker
      • Endowment Returns Tracker
      • Corporate Pension Contribution Tracker
      • Pension Fund Returns Tracker
      • Pension Risk Transfer Database
      • Future of Investments Research Series
      • Charts & Infographics
      • Polls
    • Careers
    • Events
      • View All Conferences
      • View All Webinars
      • 2022 Retirement Income Conference
      • 2022 Managing Pension Risk & Liabilities
      • 2022 WorldPensionSummit