Skip to main content
pilogo-NEW
Subscribe
  • Subscribe
  • My Account
  • login
  • NEWS
    • Alternatives
    • Consultants
    • Defined Contribution
    • Frontlines
    • Hedge Funds
    • Investing / Portfolio Strategies
    • Money Management
    • Pension Funds
    • People Moves
    • Private Equity
    • Real Estate
    • Searches & Hires News
    • Special Reports
    • H.I.G. Capital promotes 2 to co-president
      Pantheon hires global head for private debt
      Silver Lake reorganizes leadership
      Hamilton Lane promotes 3 to global investment team
    • Mercer appoints global alternatives leader for wealth business
      KPMG offloads pension advisory unit to private equity firm
      Ascensus snaps up Nyhart in latest deal
      Willis Towers Watson exec promoted to lead retirement unit
    • No uptick in hardship withdrawals seen in wake of IRS rule revamp
      Michael Hadley
      IRS hardship rules force change to plan documents
      Nancy Ross
      Sponsors take steps to reduce company-stock litigation risk
      Mike Francis
      Plan sponsors jump to meet changes over withdrawals
    • McGill Challenge winners
      HEC students win C$25,000 for sustainable investment strategy
      Warrick Dunn
      Former professional athletes want to make a different kind of impact
      Nareit diversity winners
      Nareit award winners stress diversity work isn't done yet
      Brian Collins
      Illinois Muni pension fund wins Baldrige quality award
    • Macro hedge fund Stone Milliner shutting down
      James Medeiros
      Hedge fund managers are warming up to custom funds
      Louis Bacon
      Moore Capital's Louis Bacon to quit money management business
      James Yeh
      Citadel promotes James Yeh to president and co-CIO
    • CalPERS slashes equity emerging managers program
      Canadian multiemployer plan invests in cannabis company WeedMD
      Franklin Regional Retirement launches small-cap equity search
      To cheap large-caps go the spoils
    • Investor checks on manager sexual harassment are improving, but still too low
      Apollo Global taps Bain Capital veteran to lead its Japan business
      Managers struggle to understand blockchain technology
      BlackRock's Mark Wiseman departs after failing to disclose relationship
    • CalPERS slashes equity emerging managers program
      Canadian multiemployer plan invests in cannabis company WeedMD
      South African state pension fund looks to expand unlisted assets
      Church of England Pensions Board CIO resigns
    • Mercer appoints global alternatives leader for wealth business
      Apollo Global taps Bain Capital veteran to lead its Japan business
      Realdania picks new CIO
      BlackRock's Mark Wiseman departs after failing to disclose relationship
    • Investindustrial raises €3.75 billion with seventh European buyout fund
      Sightway Capital closes first fund with $1.2 billion
      Private equity practices aired at House hearing
      Asia-focused NewQuest closes fourth dedicated secondaries fund at $1 billion
    • Schroders appoints real estate capital partners head
      CBRE acquires U.K. real estate debt investment business Laxfield Capital
      USAA to sell controlling interest in real estate unit
      Cold storage
      A hot time for those seeking the cold
    • Westfield Contributory looks to allocate to private equity, real estate funds
      Franklin Regional Retirement launches small-cap equity search
      Texas Muni assigns $50 million to private equity
      Northfield Bancorp taps Principal as record keeper for 401(k) plan
    • Investment Consultants
      The 2019 Excellence & Innovation Awards
      Top-performing managers Q3 2019
      The world's largest asset managers
  • Data
    • Research Center
    • Searches & Hires Database
    • Searches & Hires News
    • RFPs
    • Charts / Infographics
    • Sponsored Research
    • Trackers
    • Q3 2019 money manager M&A activity summary
      Q3 2019 legal overview report
      Q3 2019 searches and hires overview report
      P&I resources can give a leg up in winning new business
    • Westfield Contributory looks to allocate to private equity, real estate funds
      Franklin Regional Retirement launches small-cap equity search
      Texas Muni assigns $50 million to private equity
      Northfield Bancorp taps Principal as record keeper for 401(k) plan
    • Westfield Contributory looks to allocate to private equity, real estate funds
      Franklin Regional Retirement launches small-cap equity search
      Texas Muni assigns $50 million to private equity
      Northfield Bancorp taps Principal as record keeper for 401(k) plan
    • In-Kind Distribution Management Services (Private Markets) Provider Search
      Defined Contribution Consultant
      Consulting Services
      Technology Firms
    • To cheap large-caps go the spoils
      Only place to go is ... down
      Equity leads DC exodus amid rising markets
      Hedge fund performance fees down 11% in 2019
    • Institutional Investors: Shared Expectations, Divergent Paths
      Global Investor Study 2016
      Workplace Financial Wellness
    • U.S. Endowment Returns Tracker
      Pension Fund Returns Tracker
      Earnings Tracker
      Corporate Pension Contribution Tracker
  • Insights
    • Opinion
    • White Papers
    • Industry Voices
    • Other Views
    • Partner Content
    • Publisher's Update
    • SEC cartoon
      SEC rules need measured response
      High hopes for consistency and guidance from Scalia
      DC West poster
      Financial wellness gets spot at the table
      Times change, and that's a good thing
    • Strengthen Your Core: Flexible Multi-Sector Strategies for a Low-Yield World
      WisdomTree Yield Enhanced U.S. Aggregate Bond Fund
      Automation, lower fees driving institutional interest in factor investing and smart beta strategies
      A Great Time to Be Agnostic?
    • Gerald Cooper
      Commentary: Single-asset deals – a structure benefiting GPs and LPs alike
      Gordon Latter, Timur Kaya Yontar and Frank Benham
      Commentary: Plan sponsors, do you know your credit risk?
      Timothy Boomer
      Commentary: For plan sponsors, derivatives shouldn’t be a dirty word
      Martin Vogt
      Commentary: Renewables investing makes inroads in the Caribbean, Central America
    • Commentary: Revised statement on corporate purpose misses the mark
      Commentary: Stronger partnership needed between shareholders, managers
      Commentary: The associated costs of DB terminations
      Commentary: Support the Butch Lewis Act
    • P&I Content Solutions
      The Changing Face of Emerging Markets Investing
      P&I Content Solutions
      How ICMA-RC Creates Diversity and Investment Talent
      P&I Content Solutions
      Three conversations DC plan sponsors need to have in 2020
      P&I Content Solutions
      Automation, lower fees driving institutional interest in factor investing and smart beta strategies
    • Everything Must Change
      Tomatoes & Investments
      Baby, it’s hot outside!
  • Multimedia
    • Videos
    • Webinars
    • Polls
    • Slideshows
    • Charts / Infographics
    • Excellence & Innovation Awards 2019: Laura Mittelstaedt
      DC West 2019
      Excellence & Innovation Awards 2019: Lisa Joe
      DC West 2019: Empower Retirement's Doug Peterson on cybersecurity
    • Finding the Positive in Negative Interest Rates
      How to Position Institutional Portfolios to Capitalize on China’s Growth
      Financial Wellness: Gaining an edge with plan sponsors
      Trends in Hedge Fund Investing
    • POLL: Shared values between money managers and plan sponsors
      POLL: Climate change's impact on investing
      POLL: Ultralong-term U.S. Treasury bonds
      POLL: The best benchmark for private equity
    • view gallery
      21 photos
      The world's 20 largest retirement funds
      view gallery
      11 photos
      Top 10 DC money managers
      Top 15 managers by worldwide institutional AUM
      The 1,000 Largest Retirement Funds
    • To cheap large-caps go the spoils
      Only place to go is ... down
  • Events
    • Conferences
    • Webinars
    • East Coast DC Conference
      Fixed Income & Credit
      DC Investment Lineup
      ESG Investing
    • Finding the Positive in Negative Interest Rates
      How to Position Institutional Portfolios to Capitalize on China’s Growth
      Financial Wellness: Gaining an edge with plan sponsors
      Trends in Hedge Fund Investing
  • Careers
  • Research Center
MENU
Breadcrumb
  1. Home
  2. MONEY MANAGEMENT
October 01, 2012 01:00 AM

ETF assets rising, but some find the going tough

Market a revolving door for managers despite big inflows

  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Share
  • Email
  • More
    Reprints Print
    Staying: Deborah Fuhr says though some consolidation is likely, many firms won't abandon the market any time soon.

    The ETF market is a confusing place at the moment.

    ETF net inflows are on a pace to shatter the all-time inflow record set four years ago. At the same time, however, more money managers are exiting, and entering, the arena.

    Net inflows into U.S. exchange-traded funds totaled $130.9 billion in 2012 through Sept. 24, according to BlackRock Inc.

    This surpasses net inflows of $117 billion in all of 2011, $123 billion in 2010, and $119.4 billion in 2009. If the trend continues, 2012 net inflows would break the record of $175.7 billion in 2008, according to data from BlackRock and the ETF Association, Philadelphia.

    Yet within a two-week period in August, Russell Investments announced it was closing its 25 passively managed ETFs, just 15 months after it launched the offerings, while FocusShares LLC, the ETF unit of brokerage firm Scottrade Inc., pulled the plug on its 15 ETFs, just 18 months after they were launched. In addition, fund manager Direxion said it would close nine of its 50 ETFs.

    None of the shuttered funds had reached the $100 million mark, a commonly used measure of ETF profitability. Russell's suite of ETFs had gathered a total of $310 million, while FocusShares' 15 ETFs had a total of $100 million.

    All three firms cited problems getting significant assets as the reason for the closures.

    “We are in a difficult financial environment,” said Deborah Fuhr, a principal in the London-based ETF research firm ETFGI. “Look at the bank and brokerage industries and how many people are cutting head count. Financial firms are asking, "Where should I be spending if I have limited resources?'”

    Yet others are lining up for their turn at bat. Boston-based Fidelity Investments reportedly plans next year to offer active ETFs based on its “Select” line of industry-focused equity mutual funds.

    Fidelity spokesman Jeff Cathie said the company has formed a division to develop investment offerings based on the sector funds, but refused to say they would be ETFs. He said such an announcement would be “premature.”

    Still, the new division is being headed up by Anthony Rochte, who, as a senior managing director at State Street Global Advisors, helped run the world's second-largest lineup of ETFs.

    Fidelity would be just the latest in the line of large, established money managers that want to enter the ETF business, joining Legg Mason Inc., T. Rowe Price Group Inc. and John Hancock Financial Services Inc., among others.

    Two trends are occurring simultaneously: Bigger money managers are staking a claim to the ETF marketplace; and smaller firms are struggling to stay in business, said James Pacetti, an ETF industry consultant with S-Network Global Indexes, LLC, an index provider in New York.

    “You are going to have a big shakeout with the smaller guys who have no distribution,” Mr. Pacetti said, declining to name any firms.

    ETFGI statistics show the 13 smallest U.S. ETF providers had a combined AUM of $1.073 billion as of Aug. 31, a minuscule number in the $1.178 trillion U.S. ETF industry.

    The smallest providers as of Sept. 24, according to the BlackRock report, include tiny firms and global banks. They are AlphaClone LLC, with $3 million; Citigroup Inc., $4.4 million; Huntington Asset Advisors, $13.6 million; Factor Advisors LLC, $15.5 million; and Arrow Investment Advisors LLC, $17.6 million.

    But Ms. Fuhr said niche providers have found enough traction with their ETFs to be successful, or are willing to endure money-losing years on the hope of eventually turning a profit.

    “Many firms are going to stick with ETFs for the long run, but we are probably going to see some consolidation,” she said.

    Big players

    As the player roster changes, competition also is heating up among the three biggest ETF players — BlackRock Inc., SSgA and Vanguard Group Inc. — which control about 82% of the U.S. market and 70% of the global market,BlackRockg to BlackRock.

    BlackRock's iShares unit, the largest with $528.9 billion in U.S. ETF assets, has been losing market share during the past few years to third-place Vanguard, with $231.6 billion. Vanguard has lower fees on several key products that are similar to iShares' offerings, and on March 1 announced it was cutting its prices even further. State Street Global Advisors with $317 billion in assets is the second largest ETF provider.

    BlackRock CEO Laurence Fink said in a Sept. 10 speech that his company would lower fees on some large, liquid-core ETF's probably in the early part of the fourth quarter. The cuts could cost BlackRock $200 million to $300 million in revenue, about 3% to 7% of its overall revenue, said Luke Montgomery, an analyst with Bernstein Research in New York in an interview.

    “I fully expect the cuts to have an impact on their bottom line,” Mr. Montgomery said. “I am not convinced that lower fees will result in higher flows.”

    Mr. Montgomery said Vanguard has been very successful in the retail market, making it difficult for BlackRock to regain assets on some of its offerings, like the iShares Emerging Markets ETF, which has been overtaken by the Vanguard MSCI Emerging Markets ETF as the largest ETF in that category.

    Tracking error issues that started in 2008 in BlackRock's emerging markets ETF also turned off some institutional investors, he said.

    Daniel Gamba, New York-based managing director and head of Americas iShares institutional business, said the tracking problems were corrected more than two years ago and the ETF is now closely following the index. He said the ETF has increased the number of local securities it holds and reduced holdings of American and global depository receipts.

    Vanguard has been the flow generator this year. Its net inflows in 2012 are $41.8 billion through Sept 24, compared with BlackRock's $33.3 billion and SSgA's $25.9 billion.

    Still, BlackRock's 40.5% share of the U.S. ETF market vastly exceeds SSgA's 24.3% and Vanguard's 17.8%.

    ETFGI's Ms. Fuhr said it would be extremely difficult for any new entry to gain enough traction to compete against the big three, which have “captured around 70% of the (global) market for a very long time.”

    Below the top three, assets of ETF providers in the U.S. drop quickly.

    Invesco PowerShares Capital Management LLC, the fourth-biggest U.S. provider, has $75.4 billion in assets or 5.7% of the marketplace, with Van Eck Securities Corp. at fifth, with $27.4. billion, a 2.1% share.

    After that, no single provider has more than 1.7% of the marketplace.

    Just how much room there will be for new players or for smaller players to increase their AUM is the subject of debate.

    Optimistic market forecasters have projected global ETF assets could go to $10 trillion by 2020 from $1.2 trillion now.

    Bernstein Research's Mr. Montgomery, however, estimates a 13% compound annual growth rate for ETFs through 2025, taking the industry to $6 trillion.

    “Industry growth will disappoint more optimistic estimates and is likely to decelerate beyond the next decade, unless the ETF market can evolve away from its roots as a passive product or break into untapped distribution channels,” he said.

    Mr. Montgomery said the most significant new opportunities for the ETF industry, active ETFs and the defined contribution market, are also the most tenuous.

    ETFs are transparent by nature and disclose their holdings on a real-time basis, which could be a problem for active ETFs, he said.

    “Providers have not fully solved the challenge of offering active management without exposing managers to front-running, and they have yet to convince investors why they need” active ETFs, Mr. Montgomery said.

    Technical hurdles

    In the U.S. defined contribution area, he said, 27% of assets are invested in mutual funds, compared with less than 1% in ETFs, which must contend with technical hurdles like the ability to invest contributions in a fractional share.

    For now, all eyes are on Fidelity and its expected launch into the active ETF market.

    The company has not given specifics, but Mr. Pacetti of S-Network said the success of Pacific Investment Management Co. LLC's move into active management has paved the way for Fidelity.

    PIMCO's Total Return Bond Fund ETF, based on its Total Return Bond Fund, the world's largest mutual fund, was introduced in March and already has gathered $2.6 billion in assets.

    Mr. Pacetti said he expects Fidelity will be offering clones of some of its sector mutual funds, enabling the firm to use existing investment personnel as well as the company's distribution network.

    The growth of the ETF industry also means never say never.

    Northern Trust Corp. entered the ETF market in the spring of 2008 with 17 ETFs, including a set focused on developing and emerging markets. Yet, eight months later the company exited the market after gathering aggregate assets of less than $35 million.

    Northern Trust is having more luck with a smaller introduction of just four offerings in September 2011, which trade under the brand name FlexShares, and invest in Treasury inflation-protected securities, U.S equities and natural resources.

    As of Sept. 15, the combined funds had assets of $1.6 billion, said Shundrawn Thomas, managing director and global business head of Northern Trust's exchange-traded funds group, Chicago.

    Russell Investments, Seattle, seemed to leave open the possibility that it might return to the ETF market. In a news release announcing the closings, Russell officials said the market for the new ETFs it launched was still in the early days, and the liquidation of its ETFs “at this time” was in the best interest of the shareholders. n

    Related Articles
    Vanguard ETF index switch could help BlackRock
    ETFs are closing in record numbers
    BlackRock's launch of low-cost ETFs seen as smart move
    More pension funds see value investing in fixed-income ETFs
    ETF trading choices can affect costs, execution
    Recommended for You
    sponsored content
    Events
     
     
    Advertisement
    White Papers
    A Great Time to Be Agnostic?
    Shedding the Home-Country Bias
    Automation, lower fees driving institutional interest in factor investing and s…
    WisdomTree Yield Enhanced U.S. Aggregate Bond Fund
    Strengthen Your Core: Flexible Multi-Sector Strategies for a Low-Yield World
    View More
    Sponsored Content
    Partner Content
    How Big Data Delivers Solutions to ESG Investors
    How a Multisector Credit Approach Can Lower Risk, Increase Diversification
    ESG Investing Supplement
    Know Your DB Plan’s ‘Persona’ to Help Make the Right Strategy Choices
    Leveling the playing field for public employee retirement security
    View More
    E-MAIL NEWSLETTERS

    Sign up and get the best of News delivered straight to your email inbox, free of charge. Choose your news – we will deliver.

    Subscribe Today

    Get access to the news, research and analysis of events affecting the retirement and institutional money management businesses from a worldwide network of reporters and editors.

    Subscribe
    Connect With Us
    • RSS
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn

    Our Mission

    To consistently deliver news, research and analysis to the executives who manage the flow of funds in the institutional investment market.

    pilogo-NEW
    About Us

    Main Office
    685 Third Avenue
    Tenth Floor
    New York, NY 10017-4036

    Chicago Office
    150 N. Michigan Ave.
    Chicago, IL 60601

    Contact Us

    About Pensions & Investments

     

    Advertising
    • Media Kit
    • P&I Content Solutions
    • P&I Careers | Post a Job
    • Reprints & Permissions
    Resources
    • Subscribe
    • Newsletters
    • FAQ
    • P&I Research Center
    • Site map
    • Staff Directory
    Legal
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions
    Pensions & Investments
    Copyright © 1996-2019. Crain Communications, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
    • NEWS
      • Alternatives
      • Consultants
      • Defined Contribution
      • Frontlines
      • Hedge Funds
      • Investing / Portfolio Strategies
      • Money Management
      • Pension Funds
      • People Moves
      • Private Equity
      • Real Estate
      • Searches & Hires News
      • Special Reports
    • Data
      • Research Center
      • Searches & Hires Database
      • Searches & Hires News
      • RFPs
      • Charts / Infographics
      • Sponsored Research
      • Trackers
    • Insights
      • Opinion
      • White Papers
      • Industry Voices
      • Other Views
      • Partner Content
      • Publisher's Update
    • Multimedia
      • Videos
      • Webinars
      • Polls
      • Slideshows
      • Charts / Infographics
    • Events
      • Conferences
      • Webinars
    • Careers
    • Research Center