Skip to main content
MENU
Subscribe
  • Subscribe
  • Account
  • LOGIN
  • Topics
    • Alternatives
    • Consultants
    • Coronavirus
    • Courts
    • Defined Contribution
    • ESG
    • ETFs
    • Hedge Funds
    • Industry Voices
    • Investing
    • Money Management
    • Opinion
    • Partner Content
    • Pension Funds
    • Private Equity
    • Real Estate
    • Russia-Ukraine War
    • SECURE Act 2.0
    • Special Reports
    • White Papers
  • Rankings & Awards
    • 1,000 Largest Retirement Plans
    • Top-Performing Managers
    • Largest Money Managers
    • DC Money Managers
    • DC Record Keepers
    • Largest Hedge Fund Managers
    • World's Largest Retirement Funds
    • Best Places to Work in Money Management
    • Excellence & Innovation Awards
    • WPS Innovation Awards
    • Eddy Awards
  • ETFs
    • Latest ETF News
    • Fund Screener
    • Education Center
    • Equities
    • Fixed Income
    • Commodities
    • Actively Managed
    • Alternatives
    • ESG Rated
  • ESG
    • Latest ESG News
    • The Institutional Investor’s Guide to ESG Investing
    • ESG Sustainability - Gaining Momentum
    • Climate Change: The Inescapable Opportunity
    • Impact Investing
    • 2022 ESG Investing Conference
    • ESG Rated ETFs
  • Defined Contribution
    • Latest DC News
    • DC Money Manager Rankings
    • DC Record Keeper Rankings
    • Innovations in DC
    • Trends in DC: Focus on Retirement Income
    • 2022 Defined Contribution East Conference
    • 2022 DC Investment Lineup Conference
  • Searches & Hires
    • Latest Searches & Hires News
    • Searches & Hires Database
    • RFPs
  • Performance Data
    • P&I Research Center
    • Earnings Tracker
    • Endowment Returns Tracker
    • Corporate Pension Contribution Tracker
    • Pension Fund Returns Tracker
    • Pension Risk Transfer Database
    • Future of Investments Research Series
    • Charts & Infographics
    • Polls
  • Careers
  • Events
    • View All Conferences
    • View All Webinars
    • 2022 Retirement Income Conference
    • 2022 Managing Pension Risk & Liabilities
    • 2022 WorldPensionSummit
Breadcrumb
  1. Home
  2. Print
June 26, 2006 01:00 AM

Strategists: Don't cook the DB goose

‘Bad defined benefit plan is better than a good DC plan’

Vince Calio
  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Share
  • Email
  • More
    Reprints Print

    A defined contribution plan shouldn't be used for retirement income, two leading investment strategists say.

    M. Barton Waring, managing director of client strategy at Barclays Global Investors, San Francisco, and Laurence Siegel, director of investment strategy at the $10.7 billion Ford Foundation, New York, assert that defined benefit plans are more efficient at providing retirement savings than defined contribution plans. Their working paper, titled "Don't Kill the Golden Goose," is under consideration to be published by the Harvard Business Review.

    Pension Freeze

    Fact Sheets

    Created by the Center for Retirement Researct at Boston College

    Click for profiles of selected companies that have frozen their plans.
      The paper comes at a time when some of the largest and most established corporations increasingly are considering freezing — or already have frozen— defined benefit plans in favor of defined contribution plans. These include Verizon Communications Inc.; Northwest Airlines Corp.; UAL Corp.; International Business Machines Corp.; and Nissan North America.

      Industry experts predict that many more corporations will freeze their defined benefit plans because of looming legislative pension reform that would implement stricter pension funding rules, as well as potential changes to the Financial Accounting Standards Board's Statement 87 that would require companies to put the actual funding levels of their pension plans on to their balance sheets.

      "We regrettably but reasonably conclude that few employees can ever expect a secure and prosperous retirement, with reasonable income replacement, using the defined contribution-plan structure alone," Messrs. Waring and Siegel wrote in their paper. "We are kidding ourselves when we even speak the phrase ‘defined contribution retirement plan.' They aren't retirement plans at all, but modest savings plans."

      Four reasons

      The paper lists four reasons defined benefit plans are more cost effective and efficient than defined contribution plans:

      • In a defined benefit plan, mortality risk is shared by the overall participants. Put simply, when calculating liabilities, a corporation can determine the average life expectancy of participants. Those who die before the average age help pay the benefits for those who live beyond it. In a defined contribution plan, mortality risk is placed solely on the shoulders of the individual participant.

      • It's cheaper for a pension plan to buy annuities than it is for an individual to do so.

      • Separate-account fees for pension plans are significantly less than fees from mutual funds typically offered in defined contribution plans.

      • Assets in pension plans are overseen by skilled financial professionals, while individual defined contribution plan participants might not have the financial background to properly manage assets.

      "When a DC plan replaces a DB plan, those (advantages) are gone," said the authors in the paper.

      Addressing expense

      Messrs. Siegel and Waring also try to debunk the statement that defined benefit plans will be too expensive to run if regulatory changes are made. The paper advocates that a corporation align at least some of its pension assets to its liabilities, and add a layer of alpha on top of that.

      Additionally, if a pension plan is too expensive from an administrative standpoint and in terms of liabilities, the paper advises corporations to renegotiate the terms with participants, rather than simply kill the plan.

      For example, if a corporation determines accrued pension benefits for workers by using a 2.5 multiplier times years of service, then the corporation could lower that to 1.5, according to the paper.

      "You can make it so that a defined benefit plan costs whatever you want it to," Mr. Waring said in an interview. "If it costs too much, it doesn't mean you have to terminate it. You can renegotiate the terms of the plan. A bad defined benefit plan is always better than a good defined contribution plan — there's room to control cost."

      ‘A bit harsh'

      Jan Jacobson, director of retirement policy for the American Benefits Council, a Washington industry trade group that studies retirement issues, said that while the paper made some good points, "it was a bit harsh on defined contribution plans."

      She added the paper doesn't take into account the "developing innovations" to DC plans. "For example, in commenting on the ‘mortality risk' that Mr. Waring and Mr. Siegel talk about, some plans already do offer annuity platforms with institutional pricing. These developments are just going to accelerate," Ms. Jacobson said.

      She cited automatic enrollment in lifecycle funds and institutional pricing of fees as other innovations.

      "Yes, these innovations are available, but nobody's using them," said Mr. Siegel in an interview. "In Australia, there is a 9% mandatory contribution in private defined contribution plans (by both employer and employee). Only in the U.S. is the mandatory contribution exactly 0.00%."

      Recommended for You
      Read the print edition of P&I
      Read the print edition of P&I
      How low is low? Projections say it's not low enough
      How low is low? Projections say it's not low enough
      FINRA honors Wharton's Olivia Mitchell with Ketchum Prize
      FINRA honors Wharton's Olivia Mitchell with Ketchum Prize

      Reader Poll

      August 10, 2022
      SEE MORE POLLS >
      Sponsored
      White Papers
      Gaining Momentum: Where Next for Trend-Following?
      How Has 2022's Carnage Reshaped Global Stock and Bond Markets?
      Can Sustainable Labeling of Financial Products Prevent Greenwashing?
      Hedge Funds 2.0: Back to the future
      Is there a mid-cap gap in your DC plan?
      Why pursue direct lending in the core middle market?
      View More
      Sponsored Content
      Partner Content
      The Industrialization of ESG Investment
      For institutional investors, ETFs can make meeting liquidity needs easier
      Gold: the most effective commodity investment
      2021 Investment Outlook | Investing Beyond the Pandemic: A Reset for Portfolios
      Ten ways retirement plan professionals add value to plan sponsors
      Gold: an efficient hedge
      View More
      E-MAIL NEWSLETTERS

      Sign up and get the best of News delivered straight to your email inbox, free of charge. Choose your news – we will deliver.

      Subscribe Today
      August 1, 2022 page one

      Get access to the news, research and analysis of events affecting the retirement and institutional money management businesses from a worldwide network of reporters and editors.

      Subscribe
      Connect With Us
      • RSS
      • Twitter
      • Facebook
      • LinkedIn

      Our Mission

      To consistently deliver news, research and analysis to the executives who manage the flow of funds in the institutional investment market.

      About Us

      Main Office
      685 Third Avenue
      Tenth Floor
      New York, NY 10017-4036

      Chicago Office
      130 E. Randolph St.
      Suite 3200
      Chicago, IL 60601

      Contact Us

      Careers at Crain

      About Pensions & Investments

       

      Advertising
      • Media Kit
      • P&I Content Solutions
      • P&I Careers | Post a Job
      • Reprints & Permissions
      Resources
      • Subscribe
      • Newsletters
      • FAQ
      • P&I Research Center
      • Site map
      • Staff Directory
      Legal
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms and Conditions
      • Privacy Request
      Pensions & Investments
      Copyright © 1996-2022. Crain Communications, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
      • Topics
        • Alternatives
        • Consultants
        • Coronavirus
        • Courts
        • Defined Contribution
        • ESG
        • ETFs
        • Hedge Funds
        • Industry Voices
        • Investing
        • Money Management
        • Opinion
        • Partner Content
        • Pension Funds
        • Private Equity
        • Real Estate
        • Russia-Ukraine War
        • SECURE Act 2.0
        • Special Reports
        • White Papers
      • Rankings & Awards
        • 1,000 Largest Retirement Plans
        • Top-Performing Managers
        • Largest Money Managers
        • DC Money Managers
        • DC Record Keepers
        • Largest Hedge Fund Managers
        • World's Largest Retirement Funds
        • Best Places to Work in Money Management
        • Excellence & Innovation Awards
        • WPS Innovation Awards
        • Eddy Awards
      • ETFs
        • Latest ETF News
        • Fund Screener
        • Education Center
        • Equities
        • Fixed Income
        • Commodities
        • Actively Managed
        • Alternatives
        • ESG Rated
      • ESG
        • Latest ESG News
        • The Institutional Investor’s Guide to ESG Investing
        • ESG Sustainability - Gaining Momentum
        • Climate Change: The Inescapable Opportunity
        • Impact Investing
        • 2022 ESG Investing Conference
        • ESG Rated ETFs
      • Defined Contribution
        • Latest DC News
        • DC Money Manager Rankings
        • DC Record Keeper Rankings
        • Innovations in DC
        • Trends in DC: Focus on Retirement Income
        • 2022 Defined Contribution East Conference
        • 2022 DC Investment Lineup Conference
      • Searches & Hires
        • Latest Searches & Hires News
        • Searches & Hires Database
        • RFPs
      • Performance Data
        • P&I Research Center
        • Earnings Tracker
        • Endowment Returns Tracker
        • Corporate Pension Contribution Tracker
        • Pension Fund Returns Tracker
        • Pension Risk Transfer Database
        • Future of Investments Research Series
        • Charts & Infographics
        • Polls
      • Careers
      • Events
        • View All Conferences
        • View All Webinars
        • 2022 Retirement Income Conference
        • 2022 Managing Pension Risk & Liabilities
        • 2022 WorldPensionSummit