WEIGHTY DECISIONS: Ruling holds portfolio theory as appropriate standard
Skip to main content
pilogo-NEW
Subscribe
  • Subscribe
  • My Account
  • login
  • NEWS
    • Asset owners and the coronavirus
    • Alternatives
    • Consultants
    • Coronavirus
    • Defined Contribution
    • ESG
    • Frontlines
    • Hedge Funds
    • Investing / Portfolio Strategies
    • Money Management
    • Pension Funds
    • People Moves
    • Private Equity
    • Real Estate
    • Searches & Hires News
    • SECURE Act
    • Special Reports
    • WorldPensionSummit
    • Ron Schmitz
      Pandemic drives faster transition for Virginia to private markets
      Mubadala Investment Co. logo
      Mubadala draws on portfolio in coronavirus fight
      T.J. Carlson
      Texas Muni reduces downside risk during pandemic, finding opportunities now
      Scott Davis
      ‘Triage plan’ at Indiana system helped stem losses
    • BentallGreenOak agrees to acquire Metropolitan Real Estate Equity
      watch video
      0:45
      Private funds weathered 2020 turmoil
      Daniel McHugh
      Aviva Investors promotes from within for real assets CIO
      Marc Rowan
      More alts managers seek expansion to retail market
    • Kieran Mistry
      Hymans Robertson picks head for new non-traditional risk transfer unit
      Troy Saharic
      NEPC brings on director of new business development
      Bill Foley
      Foley-backed SPAC agrees to $7.3 billion deal with Alight
      Jason Schwarz, chief operating officer of Wilshire,
      New owners have big plans for future of Wilshire
    • OMERS CEO Blake Hutcheson
      OMERS records worst loss since 2008 on bad COVID-19 bets
      Mitchells & Butlers turns off tap on pension contributions until April
      Jerome Powell, chairman of the Federal Reserve, adjusts his glasses during a Senate Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs Committee hearing in Washington on Sept 24, 2020.
      Powell says Fed will hold steady during economic recovery
      Institutional investors mobilize for equitable global COVID-19 response
    • Database’s debut focuses on public-sector DC plans
      DC plan sponsors differ on need for annuities – survey
      Biden’s retirement idea getting the cold shoulder
      Few participants tapped savings to weather pandemic – Vanguard
    • Emissions from a smokestack in Poland
      Asset managers facing more scrutiny on ESG issues – report
      Boris Johnson, U.K. prime minister, hosts the U.N. Security Council's virtual meeting on climate change risks in London on Feb. 23, 2021
      Progress in fighting climate change falls short – U.N.
      Justin Trudeau, Canada's prime minister, smiles during a virtual joint news conference with U.S. President Joe Biden in Ottawa on Feb. 23, 2021
      U.S. joins forces with Canada on climate change
      Signage is displayed at Harvard University Health Services in Cambridge, Mass., on April 20, 2020
      Harvard endowment’s fossil-fuel investments drop to 2% of assets
    • Spirit winners
      Prudential honors young people who are helping out
      2 U.K. pension execs take on ESG investing in new podcast
      Donation illustration
      Jefferies will use trading commissions to do good
      Michael Arougheti
      SPACs ride wave as latest investment darling
    • Robert 'Rob' Shafir listens during a Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations hearing in Washington on Feb. 26, 2014
      Sculptor hedge fund hits sixth straight year of outflows
      The WallStreetBets forum on the Reddit Inc. website on a laptop computer and the GameStop logo on a smartphone in an arranged photo.
      GameStop frenzy has hedge fund managers rethinking next moves
      Gabe Plotkin, chief investment officer and portfolio manager of Melvin Capital Management, speaks during the Sohn Investment Conference in New York on May 6, 2019
      Citadel, Point72 back Melvin with $2.75 billion after losses
      Shanghai skyline
      Global hedge funds struggle even in a more open China market
    • Illinois Teachers chalks up $1.3 billion in investments, commitments
      Emissions from a smokestack in Poland
      Asset managers facing more scrutiny on ESG issues – report
      Indiana chooses PIMCO for emerging markets debt
      Boris Johnson, U.K. prime minister, hosts the U.N. Security Council's virtual meeting on climate change risks in London on Feb. 23, 2021
      Progress in fighting climate change falls short – U.N.
    • Margaret Anadu
      GSAM chooses global head of sustainability and impact
      Signage for AMP Ltd. adorns the top of a building in the Docklands area of Melbourne on May 10, 2018
      Ares, AMP eye joint venture
      Thasunda Brown Duckett
      TIAA appoints Thasunda Duckett as president and CEO
      Brightwood Capital adds senior investment professional
    • Thomas Spencer
      Oklahoma Teachers chief Tom Spencer to retire
      Swedish flags fly from a tourist souvenir shop in Gamla Stan in Stockholm on March 26, 2020
      Sweden’s AP1 gains 9.7% in 2020
      CDPQ returns 7.7% in 2020
      Cleveland-Cliffs to pour $202 million into pension plans in 2021
    • Thomas Spencer
      Oklahoma Teachers chief Tom Spencer to retire
      Margaret Anadu
      GSAM chooses global head of sustainability and impact
      Doug Heron
      Lothian Pension Fund to lose CEO this year
      Correction: PGIM Real Estate
    • Carlyle secures $4.1 billion ESG-related credit facility
      Hamilton Lane raises $3.9 billion for fifth secondary fund
      PSG closes first Europe-focused fund at $1.5 billion
      Kohlberg closes latest private equity fund at $3.4 billion
    • Sebastiano Ferrante and Jocelyn de Verdelon
      PGIM Real Estate turns to staff to fill new roles
      European managers key in on specialist strategies
      Ingrid Jacobs
      Jones Lang LaSalle brings on head of diversity and inclusion
      EQT inks deal to buy real estate manager
    • Neal and Brady
      Retirement security could be only issue both sides accept
      Retirement cartoon
      Hopes rising for retirement readiness in 2021
      Shawn O'Brien
      Annuities coming to target-date funds, but not right away
      David Ireland
      Sponsors returning to questions about in-plan annuities
    • Charging Bull, sometimes referred to as the Wall Street Bull or the Bowling Green Bull, a bronze sculpture that stands on Broadway just north of Bowling Green in the Financial District of New York City
      Top-performing managers Q4 2020
      P&I 1,000 largest retirement plans: 2021
      Retirement in emerging markets
      Outlook 2021
    • U.S. still a key market for investors
      Collected coverage of P&I's 2020 WorldPensionSummit
      Pedestrians pass a large advertisement on the Arndale Center shopping mall reading 'Act now to avoid a local lockdown' in Manchester, England
      COVID-19 puts new opportunities and risks on the agenda - WPS panelists
      Screens display stock price information over the trading floor of the NYSE Euronext exchange in Paris
      Private assets will continue to grow in portfolios – WPS panelists
  • Data
    • Research Center
    • Searches & Hires Database
    • Searches & Hires News
    • RFPs
    • Charts / Infographics
    • Sponsored Research
    • Trackers
    • Q2 2020 searches and hires overview report
      Q2 2020 money manager M&A activity summary
      Q2 2020 legal overview report
      Q1 2020 searches and hires overview report
    • Illinois Teachers chalks up $1.3 billion in investments, commitments
      Indiana chooses PIMCO for emerging markets debt
      New York Deferred Comp plan re-ups with Goldman as stable value manager
      Ann Arbor Employees taps Artisan Partners for international equities
    • Illinois Teachers chalks up $1.3 billion in investments, commitments
      Indiana chooses PIMCO for emerging markets debt
      New York Deferred Comp plan re-ups with Goldman as stable value manager
      Ann Arbor Employees taps Artisan Partners for international equities
    • Emerging Market Equity Manager Services
      Securitized Credit Manager Search
      Private Placements Asset Manager Search
      Actuarial Consultant Search
    • Taiwan Semiconductor’s No. 1 in the emerging markets book
      U.S. fixed-income returns post another positive year
      Nasdaq delivers an impressive year
      U.S. dollar's recent decline continues
    • Institutional Investors: Shared Expectations, Divergent Paths
      Global Investor Study 2016
      Workplace Financial Wellness
    • U.S. Endowment Returns Tracker
      Pension Fund Returns Tracker
      Earnings Tracker
      Corporate Pension Contribution Tracker
  • Insights
    • Opinion
    • White Papers
    • Industry Voices
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Partner Content
    • Publisher's Update
    • Tesla cartoon
      Don’t confuse wealth creation with retirement saving
      Top 1000 cartoon
      Top 1,000 retirement plans weather storm just fine
      Infrastructure cartoon
      You must go big on infrastructure, Mr. President
      Retirement cartoon
      Hopes rising for retirement readiness in 2021
    • Shifting DC Times – Winter 2021
      Bond ETFs show maturity during Covid market mayhem
      Pension Consolidation: Optimizing Scale and Maximizing Efficiency
      China is embarking on a new stage of growth
    • David Blitzstein
      Commentary: Without a national retirement policy, Americans face a future of pension crises
      Lawrence Cunningham
      Commentary: Gensler should keep Clayton’s pragmatic proxy adviser rules
      My-Linh Ngo
      Commentary: Pension funds and the role of the debt market in the fight against climate change
      Bill Peressini
      Commentary: Carbon’s elemental role in the future of impact investing
    • Writer using a typewriter
      OCIO industry needs to adopt GIPS
      Writer or journalist workplace. stock illustration
      Even as it assails China, Trump administration emulates it
      Skeptical of Main Street support for proxy adviser proposal
      Focus on manager diversity pushes asset owners’ to walk the talk
    • P&I Content Solutions
      How will gold react?
      To people shaking hands
      P&I Content Solutions
      Lessons From 2020: Today’s OCIO Model Passes a Major Test of Governance
      Sponsored Content By MassMutual
      Leveraging Data to Manage Risk
      Sponsored Content By iShares
      ETFs are becoming a cornerstone of insurance equity portfolios
    • Help us help you by supporting quality journalism
      You Must Believe in Spring
      Everything Must Change
      Tomatoes & Investments
  • Multimedia
    • Videos
    • Webinars
    • Polls
    • Slideshows
    • Charts / Infographics
    • watch video
      0:45
      Private funds weathered 2020 turmoil
      watch video
      0:59
      Secure choice and other retirement plans at a state level
      watch video
      3:33
      P&I 1,000 by the numbers 2021
      watch video
      1:33
      A look at hiring activity in 2020
    • Emerging Markets: Expanding Investors’ View
      2021: A Fixed Income Odyssey
      Technology is the New Oil: The Changing Nature of Emerging Markets
      Powering the Change: The power of diversity and inclusion
    • POLL: Working after the pandemic
      POLL: The year ahead for the 1,000 largest U.S. retirement funds
      POLL: The Biden administration’s economic plans
      POLL: Retirement issues in 2021
    • view gallery
      9 photos
      Coronavirus and the markets
      view gallery
      22 photos
      The 1,000 largest retirement funds: 2020
      view gallery
      10 photos
      Outlook 2020
      view gallery
      10 photos
      2019 as seen through the eyes of Roger
    • By the Numbers for February 2021
      Top Performing Managers of Global Fixed Income, 4th Quarter 2020
      Top Performing Managers of International Equity, 4th Quarter 2020
      Top Performing Managers of Managed Domestic Broad-Market Fixed Income, 4th Quarter 2020
  • Events
    • Conferences
    • Webinars
    • Defined Contribution Spring Virtual Series
      DC Investment Lineup Virtual Series
      ESG Investing Virtual Series
      Private Markets Virtual Series
    • Emerging Markets: Expanding Investors’ View
      2021: A Fixed Income Odyssey
      Technology is the New Oil: The Changing Nature of Emerging Markets
      Powering the Change: The power of diversity and inclusion
  • Careers
  • Research Center
MENU
Breadcrumb
  1. Home
  2. Print
January 24, 2000 12:00 AM

WEIGHTY DECISIONS: Ruling holds portfolio theory as appropriate standard

1999 saw fiduciaries winning investment prudence lawsuits

Michael Barry
  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Share
  • Email
  • More
    Reprints Print

    Several cases addressed the issue of investment prudence in 1999, and fiduciaries won many of them.

    One of the most significant, overlooked by many, was the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals decision in Laborers National Pension Fund vs. Northern Trust Quantitative Advisors Inc. et al. This case is significant because the court held that modern portfolio theory is the appropriate standard to apply in evaluating the prudence of a fiduciary's investment.

    The case involved a suit by the trustees of the Laborers National Pension Fund against one of the fund's investment managers, American National Bank of Chicago. The plaintiffs claimed that investment by ANB in stripped interest-only mortgage-backed securities, or IOs, was imprudent and violated the trust's investment guidelines.

    An IO is a right to the interest payments on a mortgage pool. When a mortgage is refinanced, the payments stop. If refinancing rates exceed expectations, there may be a significant loss. Thus, IOs lose value as interest rates go down, because refinancing rates go up. In the early 1990s, many IO investments lost money because interest rate decreases triggered an unprecedented level of mortgage refinancings. The fixed-income portfolio of the Laborer's Fund managed by ANB was among those hit.

    Following guidelines

    The plaintiffs' attack on the prudence of the fiduciary's investment was part of a charge that the fiduciary did not follow the fund's investment guidelines. The fund's general investment policy provided that investments should be made that would "preserve principal while recognizing the need for income and appreciation with a minimal risk." It also stated, however, that investments were to be diversified among government securities, bonds, mortgages, common stock, real estate, insurance company contracts, money market instruments and other appropriate investments. Bond investments were limited to federal or federal agency obligations or corporate bonds of the first three quality grades.

    The IOs purchased at ANB's direction appear to have been either agency obligations or in the highest three quality grades, and thus technically satisfied the guidelines. The lower court found, however, that the IO investments violated the "spirit" of those guidelines -- apparently because they presented a risk to principal. Moreover, the lower court rejected that the appropriateness of the IO investments should be evaluated in the context of the fixed-income portfolio managed by ANB as a whole. The court held that "it does not matter that other investment consultants in the industry held the opinion that IOs were appropriate for modern investment portfolios or that the portfolio as a whole made an adequate return."

    Risk to principal

    The court of appeals rejected the lower court's finding, pointing out that stocks, real estate and other investments authorized by the policy also involved risk to principal. It found that the lower court's analysis erroneously focused on the performance of the IOs in isolation from the performance of the rest of the portfolio. Interpreting the Department of Labor's prudence regulations, the appellate court stated a fiduciary is "required to act as a prudent investment manager under the modern portfolio theory rather than under the common law of trusts standard which examined each investment with an eye toward its individual riskiness."

    It rejected the notion that the fund guidelines required the IO investment to be analyzed in isolation. Going further, the court held that if the guidelines did require that the investment be separately analyzed, the guidelines would have to give way to the Employee Retirement Income Security Act's commitment to modern portfolio theory, which focuses on the portfolio as a whole.

    Conduct important

    The 5th Circuit emphasized that, in determining whether a fiduciary has been imprudent, "courts objectively assess whether the fiduciary, at the time of the transaction, utilized proper methods to investigate, evaluate and structure the investment; acted in a manner as would others familiar with such matters; and exercised independent judgment when making investment decisions. (ERISA's) test of prudence is one of conduct, and not a test of the result of performance of the investment. The focus of the inquiry is how the fiduciary acted in his selection of the investment, and not whether his investments succeeded or failed."

    Applying these standards, the court held ANB had acted prudently, finding ANB considered the characteristics of IOs, used stress simulation models to project performance under different scenarios and investigated the available data on the nature of the particular IOs prior to purchasing them. It further found the investment community in general did not anticipate the unprecedented interest rate drop that resulted in a dramatic increase in mortgage prepayments in 1992. Further, based on "modern portfolio ERISA principles," the use of IOs as part of a broader investment strategy was prudent and did not violate trust guidelines.

    First Union

    The implications of the Laborers case were borne out by the First Union litigation involving a suit by participants in the Signet Banking Corp. defined contribution plan (Sue B. Franklin, et al. vs. First Union Corp. et al). This suit was filed in May. No decision has been reached yet; both parties have moved for summary judgment.

    In this case, the plaintiffs claim, among other things, that when the Signet plan was merged into the First Union plan, and assets were moved out of Signet mutual funds into First Union funds, the funds into which the Signet money was transferred did not perform as well as the Signet funds. Nobody lost any money, but the participants were still complaining.

    The lesson with respect to fiduciary investment decisions: there is no safe answer. The traditional trust law approach of asset preservation no longer will suffice; participants are now prepared to sue on the basis of lost opportunity. A fiduciary must be able to defend his or her choice as the right one, not just the "safe" or "conservative" one.

    GIC litigation

    Another area in which investment prudence issues were directly addressed was in litigation over investment in GICs with insurance companies that went into receivership.

    This is an interesting area of litigation because investment decisions in 401(k) plans mostly are made by the participant. And if something goes wrong, the participant has no one to sue but himself. However, fiduciaries, often in-house, still play a big role in picking GIC investments, which sometimes go bad. Two cases decided this year dealt with GIC investments: Unisys and Crowhurst.

    In Re: Unisys Savings Plan Litigation involved a suit by the Unisys employees and employee organizations who claimed the purchase by Unisys of $217 million in guaranteed investment contracts with Executive Life Insurance Co. in 1987 and 1988, was imprudent. The GICs were purchased for stable-value funds in three of Unisys' savings plans.

    Executive Life recognized significant junk-bond losses in 1990. In April 1991, the insurer was seized by the California Department of Insurance, and Unisys' plan account balances invested in Executive Life GICs were frozen. A class of Unisys participants sued, claiming losses stemming from the freezing of the Executive Life GICs.

    Long history of Unisys

    The case has a long history. This most recent decision was a review by the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals of a lower court decision, following a bench trial undertaken after the lower court's decision -- on summary judgment and in favor of Unisys -- was reversed and remanded.

    One of the key issues was whether the initial purchase of the Executive Life GICs violated ERISA's prudence requirement. When the appellate court initially sent the decision back to the trial court, in effect ruling against Unisys, it found there were questions about whether Unisys: had adequately reviewed the data used by its consultant in recommending the initial Executive Life GIC purchase; was justified in relying on rating agencies' evaluation of the creditworthiness and claims-paying abilities of Executive Life; and had the requisite knowledge to conduct GIC bids unassisted.

    After a trial on the merits, the District Court then held, on each of the key issues, that the testimony and documentary evidence produced at trial supported Unisys' version of the facts. Unisys demonstrated that its in-house fiduciaries -- the Unisys officials with primary responsibility for selecting GIC contracts for the plans -- were competent to select GIC providers and that they engaged in a thorough review of each GIC provider.

    Transfer problems

    William H. Crowhurst et. al. vs. California Institute of Technology involved attempts by fiduciaries at CalTech to extricate CalTech 403(b) plan assets from a contract with Mutual Benefit Life Insurance Co. of New Jersey, as information came out in the press that Mutual Benefit was in financial trouble.

    CalTech fiduciaries sent in requests for individual transfers and also attempted an aggregate transfer of all assets under the contract. Before the aggregate transfer was made, however, Mutual Benefit went into receivership. Some CalTech participants then sued, claiming that by processing the individual transfers, CalTech held up the aggregate transfer.

    In holding that CalTech did not violate its ERISA prudence obligation, the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California first observed that "the prudent person standard is an objective one that focuses upon the fiduciary's conduct preceding the challenged decision. Courts must investigate whether the fiduciaries, at the time they engaged in the challenged transactions, `employed the appropriate methods to investigate the merits of the investment and to structure the investment.' "

    In view of these principles, CalTech fiduciaries could not be found to have acted imprudently. Indeed, their judgment -- that there was a risk the aggregate transfer would not take place -- was borne out by events. Mutual Benefit raised numerous problems with such a transfer and never responded to CalTech's request for a confirmation that the transfer would take place on the date specified. And, as of the date of the freeze, Mutual Benefit had taken no internal action to effect the transfer.

    Both Unisys and Crowhurst were won on the facts. In both cases, the fiduciaries were able to demonstrate that they did their homework, followed a sound procedure and documented their decision process.

    Recommended for You
    Read the print edition of P&I
    Read the print edition of P&I
    Gender diversity is improving on FTSE 350 boards
    Gender diversity is improving on FTSE 350 boards
    FINRA honors Wharton's Olivia Mitchell with Ketchum Prize
    FINRA honors Wharton's Olivia Mitchell with Ketchum Prize
    Lessons From 2020: Today’s OCIO Model Passes a Major Test of Governance
    Sponsored Content: Lessons From 2020: Today’s OCIO Model Passes a Major Test of Governance
    sponsored
    Events
     
     
    Sponsored
    White Papers
    Shifting DC Times - Winter 2021
    Bond ETFs show maturity during Covid market mayhem
    Pension Consolidation: Optimizing Scale and Maximizing Efficiency
    China is embarking on a new stage of growth
    GP-LED OPPORTUNITIES AT THE SMALLER END OF THE MARKET
    Gold Outlook 2021
    View More
    Sponsored Content
    Partner Content
    The Industrialization of ESG Investment
    For institutional investors, ETFs can make meeting liquidity needs easier
    Gold: the most effective commodity investment
    2021 Investment Outlook | Investing Beyond the Pandemic: A Reset for Portfolios
    Ten ways retirement plan professionals add value to plan sponsors
    Gold: an efficient hedge
    View More
    E-MAIL NEWSLETTERS

    Sign up and get the best of News delivered straight to your email inbox, free of charge. Choose your news – we will deliver.

    Subscribe Today

    Get access to the news, research and analysis of events affecting the retirement and institutional money management businesses from a worldwide network of reporters and editors.

    Subscribe
    Connect With Us
    • RSS
    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn

    Our Mission

    To consistently deliver news, research and analysis to the executives who manage the flow of funds in the institutional investment market.

    pilogo-NEW
    About Us

    Main Office
    685 Third Avenue
    Tenth Floor
    New York, NY 10017-4036

    Chicago Office
    150 N. Michigan Ave.
    Chicago, IL 60601

    Contact Us

    Careers at Crain

    About Pensions & Investments

     

    Advertising
    • Media Kit
    • P&I Content Solutions
    • P&I Careers | Post a Job
    • Reprints & Permissions
    Resources
    • Subscribe
    • Newsletters
    • FAQ
    • P&I Research Center
    • Site map
    • Staff Directory
    Legal
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Request
    Pensions & Investments
    Copyright © 1996-2021. Crain Communications, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
    • NEWS
      • Asset owners and the coronavirus
      • Alternatives
      • Consultants
      • Coronavirus
      • Defined Contribution
      • ESG
      • Frontlines
      • Hedge Funds
      • Investing / Portfolio Strategies
      • Money Management
      • Pension Funds
      • People Moves
      • Private Equity
      • Real Estate
      • Searches & Hires News
      • SECURE Act
      • Special Reports
      • WorldPensionSummit
    • Data
      • Research Center
      • Searches & Hires Database
      • Searches & Hires News
      • RFPs
      • Charts / Infographics
      • Sponsored Research
      • Trackers
    • Insights
      • Opinion
      • White Papers
      • Industry Voices
      • Letters to the Editor
      • Partner Content
      • Publisher's Update
    • Multimedia
      • Videos
      • Webinars
      • Polls
      • Slideshows
      • Charts / Infographics
    • Events
      • Conferences
      • Webinars
    • Careers
    • Research Center